4 Fantastic Pizza Restaurants in Fort Collins, CO

What Is It?

Slyce Pizza Co. is a beloved gourmet pizza shop located in Old Town Fort Collins, specializing in pizza by the slice. Known for its creative and unique topping combinations, Slyce is a go-to spot for locals and visitors craving delicious pizzas after a night out or during a casual lunch. With a relaxed atmosphere and a convenience that comes from a menu loaded with innovative options, it’s hard to resist the temptation of a quick bite at this delightful pizzeria.

The Experience

Stepping into Slyce Pizza Co., you’re immediately hit by the delicious aroma of fresh pizza. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, a perfect setup for grabbing a quick bite or hanging out with friends. As you glance at the display case, your eyes widen at the impressive variety of pizza slices on offer. From the classic pepperoni to the adventurous BBQ chicken pineapple and even a mouth-watering mac and cheese slice, there’s something to excite every pizza lover’s palate.

As you make your selection, the friendly staff engages with you, making recommendations and sharing enthusiasm about the featured slices. You opt for the BBQ pizza, renowned among patrons for its flavor. Each slice is sizable, practically the size of your face—and just as impressive. When your plate arrives, the perfectly crispy crust beckons you to dig in, and with the first bite, the tangy BBQ sauce mingles perfectly with the generous toppings. Honestly, it’s hard to believe you’re paying a fair $5 for something this delicious.

You settle at a cozy outdoor table. As you enjoy your pizza, you hear laughter and chatter from the nearby tables. A train runs through the heart of downtown, adding a hint of charm to your experience as you share stories over unique pizzas. Each slice is bursting with flavor, and as you wash it down with a local brew, you can't help but think you’ve found your new favorite pizza spot in Fort Collins.

With every visit, the fun factor multiplies—not only do you discover a new favorite slice, but you also enjoy the casual environment that makes it easy to connect with friends or kick back solo. Every time you think about trying something different, there’s always the temptation of the previously adored mac and cheese slice that’s still calling your name. The combination of great pizza, friendly service, and a lively setting transforms an ordinary lunch or late-night snack into an unforgettable experience.

When to Go

If you want a more laid-back experience, consider visiting Slyce during the late afternoon, before the main dinner rush starts. This is typically when the crowd is thinner, allowing you to enjoy your pizza more comfortably without the usual hustle and bustle of the evening crowd.

What Is It?

The Corner Slice is your go-to spot in Fort Collins for delicious New York-style pizza, made with fresh, quality ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere. With a fantastic menu that includes tasty pies, salads, and unique craft sodas, it's a beloved pizzeria that locals frequently recommend.

The Experience

Walking into The Corner Slice feels like a warm embrace, where the aroma of baking pizza fills the cozy atmosphere. As you order, you glance at the chalkboard menu featuring a variety of pizzas, salads, and a mouth-watering daily special. Something catches your eye – the Linden Salad, especially popular during peach season, piques your curiosity. After placing your order, you grab a seat while enjoying the upbeat vibe around you. The casual decor, friendly staff, and occasional live music create a lively but laid-back setting perfect for unwinding with friends.

When your slice arrives, it looks incredible – perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crispiness. You take a bite and can immediately tell the ingredients are fresh and flavorful. The sauce balances perfectly with the toppings, and if you're a fan of dairy-free options, you'll be thrilled to discover they have one of the best dairy-free cheese pizzas in town. Even the garlic pretzels, recommended by fellow patrons, are fluffy and delicious enough to leave you craving more.

The happy hour deals are definitely a highlight, offering slices for $2 and a draft beer for $2 as well. It’s hard not to feel like you're getting an amazing deal as you sip your local craft beer while enjoying the electric atmosphere of this community-oriented joint. You glance around and see families, friends, and fellow pizza lovers, all tucked in with pizza slices and smiles.

As you finish, you can’t help but notice how attentive the staff is, ensuring everyone is happy and satisfied. If you’ve got room left, there’s a cookie on the menu that you can’t pass up – rave reviews abound for it, and it seems like the perfect way to end an enjoyable meal at The Corner Slice. All in all, this place is fast becoming a staple for locals and a must-visit for anyone stopping by Fort Collins.

When to Go

For a more relaxed experience, consider dropping by during the late afternoon before the dinner rush, especially around 2 to 5 PM, when happy hour deals are in full swing and the crowd is lighter.

What Is It?

Totally 80's Pizza & Museum is the ultimate destination in Fort Collins for lovers of 80s culture and delicious pizza. Not only can you dig into a fantastic slice of pizza, but you can also explore an impressive collection of pop culture memorabilia from the 1980s. From arcade games to local beers, this joint brings a unique dining experience that feels like stepping back into a vibrant decade.

The Experience

As you walk through the doors of Totally 80's Pizza & Museum, you're immediately greeted by the sights and sounds of the 80s. The walls are a vibrant tapestry of nostalgia, showcasing everything from vintage posters to collectible memorabilia. Whether you’re there to relive childhood memories or introduce a new generation to the iconic decade, you can’t help but smile at the over-the-top decor. The chime of arcade games fills the air, and the irresistible scent of freshly baked pizza beckons you to take a seat.

Once you settle in, you get a firsthand look at the eclectic menu. Whether you’re craving a classic pepperoni or something with a unique twist like the Frito Pie pizza, there’s something for everyone. Many patrons rave about the garlic cheese twists, and it’s no surprise why—they're a hit across the board! As the 80s music videos play in the background, you might be tempted to sing along as you dive into a delectable slice.

The atmosphere here isn’t just about the pizza; it’s a full-blown experience. Kids and adults alike enjoy wandering through the memorabilia filled space, and the mini arcade adds an extra layer of entertainment for families. Patrons often reminisce about their own childhoods while telling stories of how exciting it is to see the toys and shows from their youth. Everyone leaves with a piece of nostalgia tucked in their hearts and usually a slice or two in their hands!

When it comes to service, guests note that it can vary. While many appreciate the friendly staff who bring the food right to your table, some find the counter-service model a tad chaotic during busy hours. However, the excellent pizza and charming ambiance often make up for any service hiccups. Guests rave about how the lively environment makes the waiting feel less like a burden and more like part of the fun as you soak in the sights and sounds around you.

When to Go

For the best experience, consider visiting during off-peak hours, like earlier or later in the evening. Arriving around 4 PM or after 8 PM might give you a chance to explore the memorabilia without the hustle and bustle of busy dinner crowds.

What Is It?

Otto PINT is a vibrant local spot in Fort Collins where craft beers and delicious pizzas come together in a relaxed, airy setting. This unique pizza joint, transformed from an old filling station, features a spacious patio and an inviting interior, making it a perfect place for a casual meal or drinks with friends.

The Experience

As you step into Otto PINT, you’re greeted by a lively atmosphere buzzing with conversation and laughter. The large garage doors are open wide, letting in a refreshing breeze, and you can smell the delicious pizzas baking in the background. You make your way to the bar, where the friendly staff is already pouring a refreshing craft beer from the extensive selection. After a moment, you notice a tempting array of unique pizzas being served to nearby tables. You decide to try the Ziggy pizza, known for its perfect combination of flavors and crispy thin crust. Upon taking that first bite, your taste buds are delighted. The crust is light but holds up well under the delicious toppings, making it easy to enjoy without it falling apart.

You take a seat on the sunny patio, enjoying the perfect weather as patrons around you chat and laugh. A couple of families with kids are nearby, and the vibe is cheerful. You spot other guests eagerly digging into a variety of pizzas, with some ordering off the mastery of specialty options that include a duck pizza that’s caused quite a stir among regulars. As the meal continues, you find yourself asking one of the servers about their vegan and gluten-free options, and she enthusiastically shares details, highlighting that they’re always accommodating to dietary restrictions, which adds an extra layer of comfort to your dining experience.

As the evening rolls on, you soak in the ambiance, from the laid-back music playing throughout the space to the smiling faces of the staff. You finish off your meal with a shared dessert, feeling satisfied not just from the good food but the friendly service you received throughout your visit. Before you head out, you glance over the impressive drink menu, contemplating what to try next time, because one visit isn’t nearly enough to uncover everything Otto PINT has to offer!

When to Go

If you’re looking to avoid the crowds, visiting Otto PINT during the late afternoon on a weekday or right when it opens is your best bet. Early evening can get quite busy, especially on weekends, which might not be ideal if you prefer a quieter experience.