6 Fantastic Pizza Restaurants in Longmont, CO

What Is It?

Antonio's Real New York Pizza, located at 325 Main Street in Longmont, is a cozy spot serving up authentic New York-style pizza that’s been winning over taste buds for over a decade. With its casual vibe and a mission to bring a slice of New York to Colorado, this pizza joint specializes in slices all day long and offers a range of delicious toppings and styles for all pizza lovers.

The Experience

You step into Antonio's Real New York Pizza on a sunny afternoon, the aroma of fresh-baked dough and simmering sauce inviting you in. As you glance at the menu, you can’t help but feel that excitement bubbling inside you, especially when you see the option to dive into a Sicilian slice or a classic New York thin crust. You decide to treat yourself to their signature Grandma pizza while also grabbing a classic pepperoni slice, just for good measure. After placing your order, you can feel the buzz in the air as patrons mingle and the friendly staff carry out pizzas to eager customers.

Once you snag your slices and find a cozy spot by the window, you take your first bite and the world around you fades. The crust is perfectly crunchy on the outside yet soft and chewy inside, just as you’d hope for in a true New York style experience. The pepperoni has just the right amount of spice, and you can’t help but think that this is truly a love letter to the classic pies of the East Coast. You reminisce about your last visit to New York City and are amazed at how this little pizza place in Longmont captured that essence so well.

As you enjoy your meal, the friendly staff periodically check on you, making sure that everything is just right. You overhear some chats about their marinara sauce being a crowd favorite, and you make a mental note to try that next time. As you finish your pizza, you feel a sense of satisfaction wash over you, knowing this could very well become your new go-to spot. Before leaving, you decide to grab a slice of their pesto and ricotta, just to go, because, frankly, who can resist? The staff packs it up with a smile, and you promise yourself to return soon.

What Is It?

Mama Mead's Pizzeria is a cozy and approachable eatery located at 900 Coffman St in Longmont, CO. Known for serving up delicious New York-style pizza, this local gem offers an array of menu items like whole pies, pasta, calzones, and subs, all crafted with fresh ingredients. You're sure to enjoy the friendly service and kid-friendly atmosphere whether you're dining in, getting takeout, or having your food delivered.

The Experience

When you walk into Mama Mead's, you're greeted by the delicious aroma of fresh pizza and a warm, welcome atmosphere. Picture yourself at one of the small tables inside, with the hustle of the kitchen in the background, where the staff are friendly and efficient. You might be tempted by their lunch special, featuring two massive slices of pizza and a drink for just five bucks! As you take your first bite of their signature Mama Bello pizza, the perfect crunchy crust and flavorful sauce take you straight back to New York. Satisfied patrons rave about their delicious gluten-free pizza too, so there’s something for everyone.

Every visit feels like catching up with an old friend. The staff here really do remember your go-to orders, making it feel personalized. If you’re feeling adventurous, the 'Meat Mania' promises a carnivore's delight, piled high with delicious toppings! And don’t skip the tiramisu; it's a crowd favorite that adds a sweet ending to your meal. You might even overhear laughter from the friendly banter between patrons and staff, enhancing the vibe of camaraderie.

If you’re with the family, you’ll appreciate the casual and kid-friendly atmosphere that encourages laughter and stories over huge pizzas. Watching the team at work in the kitchen, as they toss dough and assemble fresh pizzas, is also an entertaining experience. The excitement builds as you wait for your order, knowing it's made from scratch just for you.

After indulging in some of the best pizza around, you might find yourself chatting with fellow diners or even the owners who often take the time to connect with their guests. It’s that heartwarming kind of place where you leave satisfied and eager for your next visit, already looking forward to trying something new from their extensive menu.

When to Go

If you're looking to avoid the crowds, consider stopping by Mama Mead's during the late afternoon, around 2 PM to 4 PM. This is typically when the lunch rush has died down and before the dinner crowd swells, allowing you to enjoy your meal with a bit more space and quicker service.

What Is It?

Pie Dog Pizza, born from the culinary vision of Chefs Lisa and Patrick Balcom, is a must-visit pizza spot in Longmont, CO. This innovative eatery focuses on crafting Neo-New York style pizza, using only the finest ingredients sourced from local farms and artisans. With a commitment to organic and fresh ingredients, Pie Dog is making a name for itself among local pizza enthusiasts.

The Experience

Walking into Pie Dog Pizza, you can instantly feel the vibe - it's fun, warm, and inviting, making you feel right at home. As you scan the unique food hall concept, the smell of freshly baked pizza fills the air, and your stomach begins to rumble in anticipation. You decide to order a classic cheese pizza, just to really taste the quality of their ingredients. When it arrives, the crust is perfectly charred and crisp, while the low moisture mozzarella atop the homemade sauce looks absolutely irresistible.

As you savor each bite, the flavors dance on your palate – the heirloom flour in the crust gives a delightful snap, while the rich, organic Bianco Dinapoli tomato sauce and freshly shredded mozzarella melt beautifully together. The staff here knows how to make dining an experience, reflecting their commitment to quality and service. You notice how the owner takes pride in every pizza, ensuring that every slice tells a story of dedication and craft.

Plus, sharing this pizza joint with your fur baby only adds to the fun - Pie Dog is well-known for being dog-friendly, so why not bring your pup along? The friendly atmosphere is perfect for families, and you can't help but smile when you see smiling kids digging into their slices with joy. A routine special they offer catches your eye - a s’mores pizza that’s apparently a huge hit among visitors. You make a mental note to try it next time, especially after hearing those rave reviews about it blending flavors perfectly.

On your way out, you're greeted with gratitude from the staff, leaving you feeling valued and inspired to come back for more. Whether it’s for a casual weeknight takeout or a fun outing with the family, you’ve just discovered a new favorite spot in Longmont that checks all the boxes: great pizza, friendly vibes, and quality service.

What Is It?

Proto's Pizza in Longmont is a popular spot known for its authentic Italian pizzas, especially those with a thin crust cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. Open for takeout and curbside orders, this cozy eatery prioritizes fresh ingredients and offers a delightful range of specialty pizzas to satisfy every palate.

The Experience

As you step into Proto's Pizza, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, drawing you in. The warm light illuminates the vibrant decor of the restaurant, and you notice patrons happily chatting at the tables while others eagerly await their pizzas. You decide to grab a seat outside on the patio, enjoying the long summer evening, while glancing at the extensive menu filled with mouthwatering options. The Low Rider catches your eye, and you can’t resist ordering it alongside a refreshing arugula salad to start. The friendly staff takes your order with a genuine smile, making you feel right at home.

Minutes later, your salads arrive, adorned with vibrant greens and a drizzle of tangy vinaigrette. Every bite bursts with flavor. As you savor your meal, you can't help but notice how attentive the staff is, always checking in, creating a sense of community that truly enhances your experience. Soon enough, your pizza arrives, golden and perfectly crisp. You take a moment to admire the thin crust, before diving in, and the first bite confirms it—the toppings are fresh, and the balance of flavors gives you that satisfying nod of approval.

While savoring every slice, you overhear a table nearby raving about the clam pizza, a special they offer on Fridays, and you make a mental note to return for that treat. Before finishing, you decide to treat yourself to dessert. The tiramisu, an all-time favorite, does not disappoint and is a perfect way to end your pizza adventure. Feeling full yet not heavy, the evening at Proto’s Pizza leaves you planning your next visit—and perhaps bringing friends to share in the delightful experience.

As you prepare to leave, you can't help but notice the friendliness of the staff; they bid you farewell with welcoming smiles that will surely pull you back to this local gem in Longmont. What a gem of a place!

When to Go

For those looking to avoid the weekend crowd, a visit during late afternoon or early evening, particularly around 3 PM to 5 PM, often proves to be a more relaxed experience at Proto's Pizza. You can enjoy your meal without the bustle and still savor all that the restaurant has to offer.

What Is It?

Rosalee's Pizzeria is a charming eatery in Longmont known for its exceptional New York-style pizzas and a warm, inviting vibe. With a cozy indoor area, lovely outdoor seating, and some fun pinball machines, it's the perfect spot for families and friends to unwind and enjoy delicious food.

The Experience

Walking into Rosalee's Pizzeria, you’re greeted by a buzz of excitement—a lively crowd chatting with laughter echoing off the walls. The cozy indoor space is filled with charming decor, while the outdoor patio invites you to sit under the twinkling lights and soak in the ambiance. You make your way to the bar to order and immediately notice the friendly staff, ready to make your dining experience memorable. You decide to start with the famed garlic knots, a local favorite, and your anticipation builds as you chat with other patrons about their go-to pizzas.

As you munch on those addictive garlic knots, you’re already making plans for your pie. A server suggests the house special, filled with a delightful mix of spicy sausage and roasted jalapeños, and you can't resist. Your pizza arrives, and the smell alone has your mouth watering—a perfectly thin, crispy crust topped generously with high-quality cheese and rich tomato sauce. A quick slice yields that delightful fold, just like you remember from the East Coast.

While enjoying your meal, live music begins to play, adding to the vibrant atmosphere. Other guests share what they love about this spot—many rave about the rotating specials and the pizza by the slice, claiming it’s the best option for a quick lunch during busy workweeks. You join in on the consensus; this pizza really is a top contender, not just in Longmont, but in all of Colorado.

As the evening winds down, you can’t help but appreciate the community feel of Rosalee’s. Guests are all smiles as they chat with the owners, illustrating that this place is about more than just pizza; it’s about the genuine connections made over a shared love for great food.

When to Go

For those looking to enjoy a quieter meal, early afternoon or later in the evening, just after dinner rush hours, tends to be less busy. Aim for a visit before 5 PM or after 8 PM, and you might just find a more relaxed experience, allowing you to savor that splendid pizza without the usual hustle.

What Is It?

Urban Field Pizza and Market is a vibrant restaurant in Longmont, CO, offering a unique twist on pizza and market-style dining. Known for its delicious Detroit-style square pizzas and a cozy market filled with local goodies, it serves up everything from chef-prepared meals to fresh salads, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With options for dine-in, delivery, and catering, it truly caters to various dining preferences.

The Experience

Stepping into Urban Field Pizza and Market, you're immediately welcomed by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked Detroit-style pizza wafting through the air. As you glance around, you'll notice the modern yet cozy atmosphere, perfect for a casual meal with friends or family. Eager to dive in, you order the square pepperoni pizza—a house specialty known for its amazing balance of crispy, cheesy edges and a soft, fluffy center. Just as promised, the first bite reveals a delicious harmony between the savory sauce and rich, gooey cheese, leaving you wanting more.

While you're waiting for your pizza, you can't help but admire the charming small market area, where local pantry items beckon. Deciding to start with a salad, you choose the arugula, adorned with crispy chickpeas—that tangy shallot cider vinaigrette is an explosion of flavor that perfectly complements the freshness of the greens. You leave no piece behind. According to many patrons, the salads here are quite often the hidden gems!

Your pizza soon arrives, and it looks stunning. The square slice is generous and beautifully proportioned, filled with all the flavors you crave. You share with the group some hot honey on the side—an unexpected touch that turns the delicious into extraordinary. Patrons rave about the creative toppings, and it’s easy to see why; each piece is bursting with freshness and flavor. As you savor the last bites, you can't help but reflect on how filling yet light the meal feels, and you might even sneak a slice of someone else's pie just for good measure.

As you wind down your meal, the cheerful atmosphere shines. Laughter and chatter surround you, and the friendly staff effortlessly navigates the busy dining area, ensuring everyone feels attended to. You overhear co patrons chatting about their favorite menu items—everything from the buffalo chicken pizza to that enticing banana pudding. It’s clear that Urban Field Pizza and Market isn't just a meal; it's an experience that patrons want to repeat, again and again.

When to Go

For a more relaxed experience, it's best to visit Urban Field during off-peak hours—typically lunch times during the week or early afternoons after the lunch rush but before dinner begins. Avoiding the busy evening slots, especially around 6 PM to 8 PM, will not only provide you with a quieter atmosphere but may also lead to more attentive service.