6 Trustworthy Insurance Agents in Minneapolis, MN

Last updated in October 2024
An image of a insurance agent.

Minneapolis isn’t just known for its lakes and arts scene; it’s also a hub of talented insurance agents ready to help you navigate the sometimes-tangled world of coverage. Whether you're searching for a dependable home or auto policy, or looking for tailored business insurance, these local agents have got your back. Guests rave about how personalized the service is, with folks like the team at BlueJay Insurance Agency who take the time to craft plans suited just for you, making sure you and your family feel protected and informed. And it's not just BlueJay that's impressing locals. One Source Insurance Brokers stands out for their impressive access to over 50 top-rated companies and their knack for connecting clients with the best coverage to fit their needs. Then there’s John Lee from State Farm, known for his warm, approachable service that leaves clients feeling valued. From homeowners to business insurance, the Minneapolis insurance landscape is rich with options that prioritize customer care and smart solutions.

1

BlueJay Insurance Agency, Inc.

1229 Tyler St NE Suite 292

Minneapolis, MN 55413

(612) 236-4105

BlueJay Insurance Agency, located right in Minneapolis, MN, is an independent agency dedicated to crafting custom insurance plans that fit your unique lifestyle. The team prioritizes protecting you and your family while ensuring that the quote process is efficient and straightforward. With agents like Michael, Jay, and Seth leading the charge, you can expect top-notch service, expert advice, and competitive rates as they compare options from various top providers. Whether you're looking for home, auto, or business insurance, BlueJay is all about finding the best plan specifically tailored for you!

What People Love

  • Outstanding customer service from knowledgeable and friendly agents.

  • Quick communication and timely follow-ups.

  • Ability to save clients money while improving coverage.

  • Tailored insurance plans that fit individual needs.

  • Comprehensive comparisons between multiple insurance providers.

What People Don't Like

  • Some clients experienced occasional longer wait times for responses or quotes.

You Have to Try

  • Working with Jay, who is known for his thorough and detail-oriented approach.

  • Getting a quote from Seth for both personal and business insurance needs.

  • Exploring the competitive rates provided by Tanner, especially for auto insurance.

  • Utilizing the online data capture for quick and easy insurance comparisons.

2

Farmers Insurance - Natalie Lyon

4937 S 28th Ave

Minneapolis, MN 55417

(612) 208-0276

Located in the vibrant city of Minneapolis, Farmers Insurance - Natalie Lyon is dedicated to helping you safeguard what matters most. Offering a range of services including homeowners, renters, and auto insurance since 2012, Natalie and her team are well-known for their exceptional customer service and personalized approach. They pride themselves on being responsive, providing tailored advice, and ensuring their clients understand every step of the insurance process.

What People Love

  • Exceptional customer service from Natalie and her team.

  • Quick and thorough responses to questions.

  • Friendly and knowledgeable staff who genuinely care.

  • Competitive pricing and significant savings on policies.

  • Personalized and detailed guidance through insurance options.

What People Don't Like

  • Nothing!

You Have to Try

  • Connecting with Natalie for tailored insurance solutions.

  • Getting homeowner or auto insurance quotes from their knowledgeable agents.

  • Inquiring about their assistance with filing claims, which is reputed to be seamless.

  • Taking advantage of their competitive rates before switching providers.

3

John Lee - State Farm Insurance Agent

3957 42nd Ave S Ste 3961

Minneapolis, MN 55406

(612) 728-1000

John Lee - State Farm Insurance Agent in Minneapolis is all about providing excellent insurance services to help you manage the risks of everyday life. Known for their friendly and helpful staff, this agency makes sure clients feel supported and informed, whether you're switching insurance from another state or establishing coverage for the first time. The team's personalized approach means you won't just be a number; they genuinely care about meeting your needs and ensuring you have the right protection in place.

What People Love

  • Friendly and helpful staff that genuinely care about clients.

  • Prompt and efficient service, making insurance processes easy and stress-free.

  • Personalized attention with clear communication from agents like Gabe and Jennifer.

  • Great experience transitioning policies, particularly for newcomers or those moving from out of state.

  • Competitive pricing and savings opportunities that help clients save money.

What People Don't Like

  • Some clients wish they had more options for insurance products in specific categories.

You Have to Try

  • Getting auto and renters insurance tailored to your needs with the help of agents like Gabe.

  • Utilizing the mobile app for easy communication and management of your policies.

  • Taking advantage of available discounts and savings offers to lower your monthly premiums.

  • Participating in the comprehensive policy reviews to ensure you have adequate coverage.

4

Katie Bard American Family Insurance

5459 Nicollet Ave

Minneapolis, MN 55419

(612) 345-7900

Katie Bard American Family Insurance operates right here in Minneapolis, MN, focused on providing exceptional insurance solutions for everything from auto to life coverage. The agency is known for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, including Katie and her team, who are always eager to help you find the best policies that suit your needs. They genuinely care about their clients and work hard to ensure smooth transitions and significant savings. Whether you're a first-timer or a long-time customer, you can expect top-notch service and valuable insights.

What People Love

  • Outstanding customer service from the whole team.

  • Knowledgeable and friendly staff who tailor policies to individual needs.

  • Quick response times and efficient service.

  • Dedication to helping clients save money and find the best coverage.

  • Genuine care for clients, checking in after services are used.

What People Don't Like

  • Nothing!

You Have to Try

  • The bundle packages for insurance that can save you money.

  • Emergency roadside assistance that comes with attentive follow-up.

5

One Source Insurance Brokers

1300 Godward St NE Suite 1900

Minneapolis, MN 55413

(612) 444-6277

One Source Insurance Brokers is a full-service insurance brokerage located in vibrant Minneapolis, MN, serving both individuals and businesses across Minnesota and Wisconsin. With access to over 50 A-rated insurance companies, they offer a wide range of coverage options, including home, auto, boat, RV, motorcycle, life, and health insurance. What makes One Source stand out is their commitment to providing exceptional customer service—agents are known for their responsiveness and ability to find clients the best possible insurance solutions tailored to their unique needs.

What People Love

  • Highly responsive and attentive agents who prioritize customer needs.

  • Knowledgeable staff who help simplify the insurance process.

  • Great variety of options and competitive pricing available.

  • Outstanding customer service that makes clients feel valued.

  • Professionalism demonstrated at every step of the process.

What People Don't Like

  • A few clients feel that working through a brokerage increases costs compared to direct insurance options.

You Have to Try

  • Terry Peffer's expertise in home and auto insurance, which has saved many clients significant amounts on premiums.

  • Kyle Garman's deep knowledge of various insurance companies to find the best rates and coverage options.

  • The personalized service offered by agents like Ronnie King, who are known for their responsiveness and support.

  • The convenience of bundling insurance policies for potential savings.

6

Renewal Insurance

10026 University Ave NW Suite 103

Minneapolis, MN 55448

(651) 263-0241

Renewal Insurance is all about providing clients with tailored insurance solutions that meet their specific needs. Located in Minneapolis, they're known for their comprehensive offerings, ranging from personal to business and life insurance policies. The friendly staff is dedicated to guiding clients through the process, ensuring everyone feels informed and comfortable with their coverage. With a knack for saving clients money, Renewal Insurance stands out as a trusted partner for all insurance needs.

What People Love

  • Exceptional customer service with friendly and knowledgeable agents.

  • Ability to save clients money on their insurance policies.

  • Quick and easy quotes and claim processes.

  • Tailored insurance solutions to meet specific needs.

  • Strong communication, keeping clients updated throughout their insurance journey.

What People Don't Like

  • Nothing!

You Have to Try

  • Getting in touch with Tommie Lee for seamless policy changes and savings.

  • Working with Matt for comprehensive insurance solutions that cater to both personal and business needs.

  • Asking for a quote from Ryan for excellent communication and value.

The Glorious Places logo.
Raising up exceptional local businesses.
Made in Fort Collins, Colorado
Copyright © 2024 Glorious Places. All rights reserved.