5 Tasty Ice Cream Shops in Newark, NJ

What Is It?

Avon Icey Man has been a staple on Avon Ave in Newark since 2003, offering delicious icy treats that have kept locals coming back for more. Known for his friendly demeanor and reliable service, this ice cream spot has cultivated a loyal customer base that appreciates not just the flavors but also the warmth of the service.

The Experience

You stroll down Avon Ave on a warm summer day, the air is filled with chatter and laughter, and your thoughts quickly drift to one place – Avon Icey Man. This isn’t just an ice cream shop; it’s a hub for the community, a place where locals gather and bond over a shared love for icy treats. As you approach, you’re greeted with the sight of a bright cart brimming with vibrant colors from an array of flavors. You can’t help but smile as you see families and friends enjoying their iced cups, laughter echoing around you.

When it's your turn, the Icey Man greets you with a warm smile, and you can feel the genuine respect and professionalism he brings. You decide to take him up on the offer to mix five different flavors in one cup - how can you resist playing mad scientist with all those tasty options? It’s a delightful experience to combine your favorite flavors, creating a custom masterpiece with the sweetest tastes of summer. As you take your first scoop, the icy texture refreshes you instantly, reminding you just how special these treats are.

It’s not just the ice that enchants you; it’s the connection. You watch as he interacts with children, making them laugh and encouraging them to try new flavors. His infectious positivity radiates, something that’s not just about ice cream but community. Every patron feels recognized and cherished, turning a simple icy treat into a warm moment of connection.

As you savor each delightful bite, you can’t help but commend the Icey Man for his dedication. The reviews flood your mind – he’s survived storms and society's ups and downs, yet here he stands, still serving up joy. It’s a reminder of the timeless charm of small businesses that make cities like Newark feel like home.

What Is It?

M2ICE is a charming dessert spot in Newark, serving up a delightful array of Colombian treats like cholados, fresh fruit, and delicious milkshakes. Renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and creative ice combinations, this place is perfect for anyone looking to cool down with something sweet and refreshing. Whether you’re after an ice cream cone or a traditional dessert, M2ICE has something to tickle your taste buds.

The Experience

Walking into M2ICE, you’re immediately hit by the colorful displays and the mouthwatering aroma of fresh fruits. You’re greeted by a lively atmosphere that instantly feels inviting. After scanning the menu filled with enticing options, you decide to try the cholado. When it arrives, it’s a masterpiece—layer upon layer of vibrant fruits like strawberries and bananas, all over shaved ice. The bright colors just scream summer! As you dig in, every spoonful is as delightful as the last. It’s refreshing, sweet, and could definitely take you back to those joyful summer days of childhood.

While savoring your cholado, you can't help but notice the customers around you, all smiling and enjoying their own picks – some munching on arepas and others enjoying milkshakes that look almost too beautiful to drink. You start to feel that warm sense of community; it’s one of those places where you can strike up a conversation with your neighbor about their favorite flavors. You hear mention of the special drinks named after popular artists like Bad Bunny and Karol G, and your curiosity only heightens.

After your cholado, you decide to treat yourself to a milkshake. You place your order, and you can see the staff working with genuine enthusiasm. They craft your shake with fresh ingredients, and when it arrives, it’s a delightful creamy delight, perfectly sweetened. The combination of flavors just hits the right spot. You’re feeling satisfied, but the thought of trying an elote with Cheetos has now firmly planted itself in your mind for next time!

As you finish up, you notice how clean and well-kept the little shop is, reflecting the pride they take in their offerings. Everyone you see seems to be having a great time, and the hospitable service really amplifies the charm of the place. When you finally leave, you’re already planning your next visit; M2ICE has completely stolen your heart, and your taste buds!

What Is It?

Magic Cones Plant Based Ice Cream Parlor is a delightful vegan ice cream destination that serves up a variety of flavors from traditional vanilla to exotic soursop. With a focus on health-conscious options, everything here is not only plant-based but also alkaline, kosher, and halal. Patrons can personalize their treats with an impressive selection of toppings, including hemp seeds, sprinkles, and fresh fruit, making each visit a unique experience. This charming parlor is an extension of a community-focused eatery, promising delicious, guilt-free indulgence that everyone can enjoy.

The Experience

As you step into Magic Cones Plant Based Ice Cream Parlor, you're greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that instantly puts you in a good mood. The delightful aroma of sweet treats fills the air, and you can't help but smile as you scan the vibrant flavors on display. Your eyes light up at the thought of indulging in delicious, plant-based ice cream without any guilt. As you approach the colorful menu, you experience a swirl of excitement to pick out a flavor—will it be classic chocolate, tropical soursop, or perhaps cherry vanilla?

Once you decide, the friendly staff is more than eager to help you build your perfect treat. They greet you with kindness, and with each scoop, the anticipation builds. You can’t wait to try the personal touch of toppings, so you opt for a generous drizzle of chocolate sauce and a handful of crunchy chocolate chips. You sit at one of the stools inside, savoring every creamy bite of this unique dessert. The flavor is harmoniously rich, and you can’t help but think about how hard it is to believe this is vegan!

Amidst laughter and chatter from other guests enjoying their own treats, you can’t help but notice the joy on a kid's face nearby. You realize the ice cream is not just for adults; kids, like the one who’s lactose intolerant, are also loving every scoop here. You overhear a parent raving about how their child is absolutely enthralled with the dessert—confirming it’s a hit for families.

As you wrap up your visit with a satisfied smile, you contemplate trying another flavor on your next visit. With the Adventure of tasting soursop still ahead, the delightful experience at Magic Cones makes it clear you’ll be back soon for more of this extraordinary plant-based indulgence.

What Is It?

Since 1939, Nasto's Ice Cream Co. has been serving up homemade ice cream and traditional desserts in Newark, NJ, bringing a slice of Old World charm to the New World. With a reputation for quality and a delightful variety of flavors, this family-run gem has become a staple in the Ironbound district, beloved by locals and visitors alike.

The Experience

Walking into Nasto's on a sunny afternoon, you're immediately greeted by the sweet aroma of their fresh ice cream, a treat that feels both nostalgic and inviting. The friendly staff welcomes you with smiles, eager to guide you through their colorful display of flavors. You can't help but be drawn to unique options like sweet corn and avocado, alongside classics like cookies and cream. The atmosphere buzzes with chatter and laughter as families enjoy their treats outside, soaking up the neighborhood's warmth and charm.

You decide to try the pistachio ice cream recommended by fellow patrons, and as your spoon dives into the creamy scoop, you taste the rich, nutty flavor that lingers just right on your palate. You reminisce about the last time you indulged in a homemade cone like this — it’s simply delightful! As you savor each bite, you overhear the laughter of kids nearby, enjoying flavors like cookie monster and the ridiculously delicious peanut butter ice cream.

After being so impressed with the ice cream, you can't resist checking out the desserts too. You spot the tres leches cake that has received rave reviews, and you decide to order a slice. Oh man, it’s so good that it practically melts in your mouth! An old favorite, it’s clear this cake has been perfected over the years.

A few moments later, as you step outside to enjoy your treats in the sun, you can't help but feel grateful for this little gem—it's not just the ice cream but the community vibe that draws you back to Nasto's again and again. You watch as families enjoy ice cream cakes for birthday celebrations and couples sharing scoops, all while the friendly staff continue their great service, making you feel right at home.

When to Go

If you're looking to beat the crowds at Nasto's, aim for a weekday afternoon. Earlier in the day or right after lunch tends to be quieter, as the evenings, especially around dinner time, draw in many patrons looking for a sweet treat. This way, you can enjoy your ice cream without having to navigate through a bustling crowd.

What Is It?

Salaam Ice Cream Parlor in Newark is where delicious meets diverse! This local gem specializes in kosher and vegan ice cream, offering a fresh, creamy, and exciting treat for everyone. Whether you’re looking for a classic scoop or something special, this spot has got you covered with plenty of flavors and satisfying desserts that keep customers coming back for more.

The Experience

As you step into Salaam Ice Cream Parlor, you're greeted by a colorful, clean space that immediately makes you feel at home. The friendly staff welcomes you with warm smiles as you peruse their tempting menu. You can almost taste the love that's gone into crafting these recipes, and it shows as you watch fellow guests enjoying their treats. The aroma of fresh ingredients fills the air, drawing you in closer to the enticing display of ice cream flavors. You decide to indulge in a rich, creamy milkshake, perhaps one with strawberries or even a red velvet twist. Oh, and let’s not forget about the brownie sundae that many patrons rave about!

You settle into one of the outdoor seating spots, enjoying the pleasant atmosphere. What’s that? You overhear kids giggling and sharing flavors of the butter almond ice cream—such a crowd favorite! You take a sip of your milkshake, and it’s everything you hoped for—rich, velvety, and simply delicious. It’s not just the ice cream that impresses you; the service is exceptional. The staff is attentive but not intrusive, making sure everyone feels welcomed and content.

As you enjoy your sweet treats, you can't help but notice how the parlor has become a community hub. Folks are chatting, laughing, and making memories here. There’s something special about a neighborhood ice cream spot that brings people together, and you feel lucky to be part of it. The conversations range from recommendations for the best flavors to the latest happenings in Newark.

Even as you prepare to leave, you consider returning soon. You overhear someone mention a new flavor that’s just been added, and your taste buds practically dance at the idea of coming back. It’s easy to see why Salaam Ice Cream Parlor has transformed into a go-to spot for folks in the area—the experience is just as satisfying as the ice cream itself!