6 Fantastic Pizza Restaurants in Jacksonville, FL

What Is It?

Carmines Pie House is renowned in Jacksonville for its delicious selection of Chicago-style deep-dish and New York-style pizzas. With a fun, funky decor, this pizzeria is a favorite local spot to enjoy hearty Italian food, including pastas, wings, and decadent desserts. Whether you're dining in, ordering takeout, or getting it delivered, Carmines aims to create an unforgettably satisfying dining experience.

The Experience

Walking into Carmines Pie House feels like stepping into a cozy gathering of friends. The eclectic decor, from quirky knick-knacks to vibrant murals, sets the scene for a fun dining experience that immediately puts you at ease. As you settle into your booth, the friendly service makes you feel like part of the family. And speaking of service, if you’re lucky, Richard might take your order. His attentive nature, quick wit, and genuine kindness have drawn praise from many patrons, creating a communal vibe that makes each visit special.

As you scan the menu, don’t miss the Chicago deep-dish pizza, reported to be a revelation to both locals and visitors. The thick, cheesy layers piled high with ingredients make it a filling feast. If that isn't your thing, reports suggest the New York-style pizzas are equally scrumptious, with a delightful crust and flavorful sauce. Many have lauded the robust sauce, which adds an essential kick to each slice. You can also indulge in wings, calzones, and a range of pasta, leaving little room for disappointment.

On your visit, don't forget to save room for dessert! Guests rave about the Oreo cake and cannolis, which entice you to linger just a bit longer. And with a nice selection of beers and wines, you might just find the perfect pairing to complement your meal. As the evening rolls on, the laid-back atmosphere, bolstered by upbeat music and friendly chatter, only adds to the enjoyment of savoring a delicious slice (or two). The memories created here are bound to keep you coming back for more.

However, be prepared for a potentially warm experience if you visit in the peak summer months. Some guests have commented on the lack of air conditioning, making it a little toasty inside. A bit of patience might be required, as the restaurant tends to fill up quickly during busier hours with families and groups all drawn to the fabulous flavors on offer. Fortunately, Richard's cheerful presence and the overall commitment to customer service help smooth over any bumps in the meal.

When to Go

For a more serene experience, consider visiting during weekdays, especially for a late lunch or an early dinner when the crowd is lighter. Avoid popular dinner hours around 6 PM to 7 PM if you'd prefer a more peaceful dining atmosphere.

What Is It?

Crispy's Springfield Gallery is a charming eatery located in a historical brick-lined space in Jacksonville. Known for its elevated pizzas and sandwiches, this delightful spot boasts a lively atmosphere and an impressive bar. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a fun night out, Crispy's has a little something for everyone.

The Experience

Stepping into Crispy's Springfield Gallery feels like entering a friendly neighborhood spot where everyone knows your name—well, sort of! You find a cozy spot at the bar, and even before you settle in, the bartenders greet you with warm smiles and quick service. Can you already smell the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air? It’s captivating! You notice the vibrant artwork displayed—it adds character to this historic space.

As you glance at the menu, there’s so much tempting you, but the shrimp queso stands out as a must-try. You indulge, and it lives up to the hype! Next up, you can’t resist trying their famous garlic knots paired with one of their signature pizzas. The crust is perfectly crispy and the toppings generous. Each slice you take is a delightful blend of flavor that makes you want to savor every bite.

The ambiance grows more lively as the place fills up with friends catching a game on the many TVs scattered around. The drinks flow, and soon enough, you’re laughing and enjoying the vibrant energy around. The atmosphere is almost electric, making you feel right at home. Whether folks are stopping by for a late-night slice or a casual dinner, the friendly vibes keep things light and fun.

Before you know it, dinner turns into dessert—the infamous lemon mascarpone cake definitely catches your eye. And, just like everything else, it’s beautifully crafted and delicious. You leave feeling satisfied, uplifted, and with plans to return soon. After all, this quaint gem of Jacksonville has a charm that keeps you coming back for pizzas and good times!

When to Go

If you're aiming for a quieter dining experience, consider visiting during the weekdays around lunchtime, or after the dinner rush, which typically starts to taper off around 8 PM. This latter timeframe can make it easier to enjoy the atmosphere without feeling overwhelmed by the busy crowd.

What Is It?

Eleon Pizza & Pastry is a delightful spot in Jacksonville where guests can enjoy a fantastic blend of authentic pizzas, mouth-watering pastries, and refreshing beverages. This family-owned cafe prides itself on using fresh ingredients and providing a warm, inviting atmosphere for all who walk through its doors. Whether it's a quick bite for breakfast or a leisurely dinner, there's something for everyone at Eleon.

The Experience

Stepping into Eleon Pizza & Pastry, you're instantly enveloped in a warm, friendly atmosphere that feels like home. The inviting aroma of freshly baked pizzas mingles with the sweet scent of pastries, making it hard to choose where to start. You decide to sit outside, soaking in the view of the tranquil lake while you savor the delicious Greek salad that’s not only generously portioned but bursting with flavor. Then comes the star of the evening – the margherita pizza. You're impressed by the crisp crust, which is perfectly airy, and the fresh mozzarella paired with fragrant basil creates a delightful taste that keeps you coming back for more.

As you finish the pizza, you can't help but eye the dessert display that looks like it was taken from a gourmet magazine. You opt for the cannoli, which turns out to be even better than expected; it's creamy, indulgent, and simply divine. The friendly staff make a point to check on you, adding a personal touch to your experience. You overhear another family talking about their own delicious dishes and think about how great it is to find a local spot that caters to all ages – kids and adults alike are raving about their meals.

You take note of how clean and well-organized the cafe is, with its charming decor and relaxing ambiance playing in the background. When you glance at the menu, you realize you could spend hours sampling all the exciting options. Someone at the next table orders one of those iconic monster shakes, which not only looks stunning but has flavors that match the visual appeal, sparking your curiosity for next time.

On your way out, you chat with one of the owners who is genuinely engaging and even offers you a taste of a new pastry they’ve just concocted. It’s safe to say that Eleon has made a lasting impression on you; the combination of fantastic food, friendly service, and a cozy setting makes it a must-visit spot on your list for future meals and celebrations with family and friends.

When to Go

To enjoy a more relaxed atmosphere at Eleon Pizza & Pastry, aim to visit during off-peak hours. Mornings before 11 AM or early afternoons around 2 PM are typically quieter times, allowing you to savor your meal without the hustle and bustle of peak dinner traffic, which usually occurs between 6 PM and 8 PM.

What Is It?

Joseph's Pizza on Main St is a long-established Italian eatery that's well-loved by locals for its family-friendly atmosphere and delicious offerings. Known for its creative pizza combinations, traditional pasta dishes, and delightful gelato, this cozy restaurant has become a staple in Jacksonville since its inception. It's a great spot for gatherings, whether with family or friends, and always feels like a taste of home.

The Experience

As you walk into Joseph's Pizza, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizzas and simmering pasta hits you, making your mouth water instantly. The warmth of the atmosphere isn’t just from the delicious food; it’s also the friendly staff, who seem genuinely happy to be there. After a quick glance at the menu, you decide on the Joseph's Special pizza, knowing it’s a crowd favorite. When the pizza arrives, it’s a sight to behold—piled high with colorful toppings and dripping with cheesy goodness. The first bite is nothing short of heavenly, a perfect harmony of flavors that feels both comforting and exciting.

Post-pizza, you can’t resist trying their famous gelato. It’s like sinking into a creamy dream, the perfect sweet treat to end your meal on a high note. As you take in the charming murals and nostalgic décor around, you realize just how rich in history this place is, enhancing your dining experience further. The attentive staff ensures your glasses are never empty, and they’re quick to offer suggestions if you’re in the mood to try something new.

While eating here, you overhear another table enjoying an Italian wedding soup, and you can’t help but feel a pang of curiosity to try it on your next visit. The sense of community is palpable; families, couples, and friends gather over hearty meals, swapping stories and laughter. This is more than just a meal; it’s a time to connect with others and savor the good things in life. As you wrap up with a slice of their amazing cheesecake, you promise yourself to return soon, knowing that you’ve discovered a true gem in Jacksonville.

When to Go

If you're looking to enjoy a quieter meal at Joseph's Pizza, consider visiting just after the lunch rush or late in the afternoon before the dinner service picks up. Typically, arriving around 3 PM can help you avoid the busiest hours and enjoy a more relaxed dining atmosphere.

What Is It?

Moon River Pizza is a funky little pizzeria in Murray Hill, Jacksonville, known for its custom and specialty thin-crust pies served in a colorful and inviting atmosphere. With a great selection of wines and beers, this spot is perfect for pizza lovers looking to enjoy a delicious meal in a fun setting.

The Experience

Walking into Moon River Pizza, you're immediately greeted by the vibrant atmosphere filled with quirky art and the delightful sound of music playing in the background. The friendly staff doesn’t just serve food, they create an inviting ambiance that makes you feel right at home. You grab a seat and prepare to explore their extensive menu filled with tasty options like the popular T-Rex pizza, a meat lover's dream that promises generous portions of toppings. As you mull over the choices, the scent of freshly baked pizza wafts through the air, making your stomach rumble in excitement.

Once you’ve placed your order, the attentive staff checks in to make sure you have everything you need while keeping the drinks topped off. You’re told by a nearby patron that the gluten-free crust is a solid option for those with dietary restrictions, and they don’t disappoint. Before long, your pizza arrives hot and bubbling, with the crust perfectly crisp and the toppings fresh and flavorful. Each bite is a happy marriage of textures and tastes, putting a big smile on your face as you savor the moment.

As you enjoy your meal, you can’t help but notice the easy camaraderie between diners and staff alike. Families, friends, and couples fill the space, all laughing and chatting, making the place feel alive. Children receive complimentary dough to play with while they wait for their meals, adding a family-friendly touch that’s hard to beat. The vibe is casual yet invigorating, making it easy to relax and enjoy your company.

After finishing your pizza, you might just indulge in one of their infamous cheesy breadsticks, with many patrons praising them as a must-try. With a full belly and content heart, you're ready to plan your next visit, knowing you'll come back for that inviting atmosphere and excellent service that Moon River Pizza is renowned for. Whether you dine in or take out, this local gem is sure to make your day a little brighter.

When to Go

To avoid the crowds and enjoy a more relaxed dining experience at Moon River Pizza, aim to visit during late lunch hours. Arriving just after the lunchtime rush means you can enjoy the same delicious food without the bustling evening crowds. This is especially ideal if you prefer a quieter atmosphere to enjoy your meal.

What Is It?

Stoner's Pizza Joint Jacksonville Mandarin is a local gem offering freshly made pizza, mouthwatering wings, and delectable desserts like their famous Half-Baked cookies. Known for their laid-back atmosphere and responsive staff, they focus on quality and quick service, making it a popular choice for both takeout and delivery in Jacksonville.

The Experience

You roll into Stoner's Pizza Joint on a casual afternoon, greeted instantly by the upbeat vibe and the scent of delicious pizza wafting through the air. The moment you approach the counter, you’re met with friendly faces, ready to help you navigate their tempting menu. Maybe you decide to stick with the classic pepperoni or get adventurous with a Philly cheesesteak pizza, knowing the ingredients are fresh and the crust is perfectly crispy. As you wait, you can’t help but notice how clean and organized the place is, giving you that reassuring feeling of a well-run establishment.

After just a short wait, your order comes out steaming hot and ready to devour. You give in to the temptation of a cookie and order a few to take home. Each bite of that half-baked cookie is a delight, with just the right amount of gooeyness that makes you feel like you’ve hit the dessert jackpot. You savor the moment and think about how each meal here feels like a mini-celebration.

The staff is engaging and genuinely enthusiastic, making sure you have everything you need. Whether you’re dining solo or bringing the whole crew, there’s always a warm atmosphere that feels inclusive. If the day leans toward a busy evening, you know they’ll still get your food out promptly—no grumpy faces here!

As you finish up and gather your things, you reflect on how delightful your meal was and how you’ll be back for a late-night cookie splurge again soon. It’s clear this spot has earned its reputation—hands down some of the best pizza and cookies in Jacksonville, served up with care and tons of good vibes!

When to Go

If you’re looking to avoid the crowds, aim for a visit during the early afternoon or on weekdays when it’s less hectic, particularly before the evening rush hits around 7 PM. This way, you can enjoy your meal with ease without having to jostle for attention or space.