7 Trustworthy Insurance Agents in Longmont, CO

Last updated in September 2024
An image of a insurance agent.

In Longmont, finding an insurance agent who genuinely cares about your needs can feel like a challenge. But lucky for you, this charming city is home to a variety of fantastic insurance agencies ready to take the stress out of coverage shopping. From auto to commercial policies, Longmont's insurance agents prioritize personalized service and straightforward communication, making sure you leave feeling confident in your decisions. Whether you're visiting Evertree Insurance, where the friendly team treats you like family, or Mountain Insurance, known for its knowledgeable staff and tailored solutions, there's a vibe of community and support throughout. With so many glowing experiences shared by local patrons, you'll find that securing coverage in Longmont can be far from daunting. These agencies don’t just sell policies; they build relationships and take the time to understand your unique situations. At places like Bassett Insurance Group and Rocky Mountain Insurance Center, guests rave about the welcoming atmosphere and comprehensive options that cater to both your personal and business needs. With agents who explain those pesky insurance terms in a way that makes sense, it’s no wonder visitors feel empowered and informed after their visits. Let’s dive into some of the top picks in Longmont's insurance scene to help you find the best fit for safeguarding what matters most to you.

1

Bassett Insurance Group

1079 S Hover St # 200

Longmont, CO 80501

(303) 776-7676

Pros and Cons

  • Friendly and professional service

  • Tailored insurance options to meet specific needs

  • Quick response to questions and claims

  • Proactive follow-ups after severe weather events

  • Strong community ties and local presence

  • Occasional discrepancies between quoted and actual costs

  • Some transition processes can be confusing

  • A bit overwhelming with too much information at once

What Is It?

Bassett Insurance Group is a reputable insurance agency based in Longmont, CO, providing customized insurance solutions for homes, autos, and businesses. With a dedicated approach and connections to top-tier carriers like Safeco and Progressive, they strive to protect your assets while ensuring you receive the best coverage possible.

The Experience

Stepping into Bassett Insurance Group feels like being welcomed by an old friend. Right from the start, you’re greeted with warmth and professionalism that immediately puts your insurance woes at ease. You sit down with an individual who's not just knowledgeable but genuinely excited to help you navigate the sometimes murky waters of insurance. They take the time to listen to your specific needs, whether you're looking for home, auto, or business coverage. It’s refreshing to work with someone who tailors solutions just for you instead of pushing a one-size-fits-all policy.

As the conversation flows, you find yourself feeling empowered. It turns out that the complexities of insurance aren’t that daunting when there’s someone like this willing to break everything down in real terms. They help you understand the ins and outs of different policies, explaining the pros and cons with care and clarity. By the end of your meeting, you're not just making a decision; you’re feeling informed, comfortable, and confident in what you’ve chosen.

Throughout the process, you can’t help but notice how responsive they are. Whether you have urgent questions or need tweaks to your existing policies, it feels like you have someone in your corner who’s just a phone call or email away—even during holidays! And, when it comes to handling claims or adjustments, they step in to offer proactive reminders, making sure you’re covered whenever the unexpected hits, like the notorious Colorado hailstorms.

It’s safe to say that leaving Bassett Insurance Group is a little different than when you walked in. You leave with a strong sense of security, knowing that your assets are in good hands with a team that's committed not just to getting you a policy but to being a trusted partner in your insurance journey.

2

CYA Insurance Colorado

710 Tenacity Dr UNIT 201

Longmont, CO 80504

(720) 442-1544

Pros and Cons

  • Personalized and attentive service from knowledgeable agents.

  • Competitive pricing and tailored coverage options.

  • Quick response times and helpful communication.

  • Community-focused approach, with a strong emphasis on customer satisfaction.

  • Some patrons desire clearer communication on policy options.

  • Follow-up response times can vary, not always as swift as desired.

  • A few customers feel additional clarity during the initial process would be beneficial.

What Is It?

CYA Insurance Colorado is your local go-to for all types of insurance needs, from auto and home to commercial and individual coverage. Known for their personalized service and deep expertise, their dedicated agents work hard to provide tailored solutions that fit every client’s unique requirements. With competitive rates and a focus on customer satisfaction, CYA Insurance stands out as a trustworthy partner in safeguarding what matters most to you.

The Experience

Walking into CYA Insurance Colorado, you immediately feel a sense of being in good hands. The warm, welcoming ambiance sets the tone for a personalized experience, and you quickly notice how attentive the agents are to each visitor. It doesn’t take long for you to realize that this place is different. Maybe you’re there to explore your auto insurance options—perhaps it’s time to tackle those youthful drivers in the family. The agent you connect with is communicative and answers all your questions with ease, leaving no stone unturned in ensuring you know exactly what you're getting into.

The focus is on making sure you’re covered properly, and the whole process is easygoing. Your agent runs through various options, presenting multiple companies to choose from, and you appreciate having the power to compare rates without feeling pushed into a decision. You’ve heard about CYA’s competitive prices, but hearing it right from the source makes you feel at ease. The agent even takes the time to break down complex terms, making them accessible to everyone, and it feels like you’ve got a partner looking out for you rather than a sales pitch.

As a small business owner navigating the world of insurance, you see the value in having someone like CYA in your corner. They take the effort to understand your business needs, guiding you through the intricacies of professional insurance while connecting the dots that make a genuine impact. By the end of the meeting, not only do you feel better informed, but you've also saved money with better coverage tailored to your circumstances.

You can't help but feel grateful for the community-focused experience at CYA Insurance—a local gem that’s more interested in safeguarding its patrons than just making a sale. When you leave, you know your insurance needs are well taken care of, and you’re not going to hesitate to recommend them to your friends and family who may be looking for a reliable insurance partner.

3

Evertree Insurance

2330 Main St Unit H (2nd Floor

Longmont, CO 80501

(303) 774-8810

Pros and Cons

  • Friendly and knowledgeable team dedicated to helping clients.

  • Efficient and thorough process in finding the best coverage with competitive rates.

  • Strong customer service with quick responses and personal attention.

  • Agents like Kelli and Doug frequently praised for their professionalism and support.

  • Inconsistent communication, especially during agent transitions.

  • Some clients felt a lack of clarity in policy details and follow-ups.

What Is It?

Evertree Insurance, formerly known as 1st American Insurance Agency, offers a wide array of personal and commercial insurance services to clients throughout Colorado and nearby states. They pride themselves on delivering quality customer service while partnering with trusted insurance providers to find the best coverage at competitive rates. Whether you're looking for auto, home, or commercial insurance, Evertree's team is dedicated to meeting your unique needs with tailored solutions.

The Experience

When you step into Evertree Insurance in Longmont, you're not just another client; you're treated like family. The knowledgeable team is happy to welcome you with friendly smiles and an inviting atmosphere. It’s great to see how perks like quick service and thorough explanations help ease the stress typically associated with insurance shopping. Imagine discussing your coverage needs with someone who takes the time to explain every detail in a way that makes sense! From the moment you walk in, you sense that everyone, from Kelli to Doug, is eager to lend a hand in finding you the best plan possible.

As you dive into discussing policies, the staff are quick to offer comparisons across different providers, making the usually daunting task of sifting through insurance options feel refreshingly simple. Each agent seems dedicated, armed with a wealth of knowledge to answer all your questions. If it’s your auto or home policy you’re setting up, you can rest easy knowing they’re putting in the work to secure great rates. Many patrons have sung praises for how these agents are able to identify the best coverage that suits their lifestyles without breaking the bank.

You might even remark on the seamless communication. Call or email, and you'll find the response is always prompt and informative. Kelli, in particular, stands out as a rock star, often recognized for going above and beyond to ensure that you’re not just another number—she’s determined to protect your interests. This personal touch is refreshing, making many customers feel valued and cared for, which is often hard to find in today’s fast-paced world.

As you leave, you've not just signed up for insurance, but you also feel like you've made a connection. The team's commitment doesn’t stop at the paperwork; they genuinely care about your peace of mind. Whether it's helping out post-claim or offering assessments annually, Evertree Insurance seems to walk the extra mile with you, leaving you confident that you made the right choice.

4

Flores Insurance Agency

809 Main St

Longmont, CO 80501

(303) 678-8660

Pros and Cons

  • Warm, friendly atmosphere makes you feel right at home.

  • Knowledgeable agents provide detailed and personalized service.

  • Wide range of insurance options available to suit various needs.

  • Offers notary public services on-site for added convenience.

  • Occasional longer wait times, especially during peak hours.

  • Some visitors desire even more detailed explanations of policies.

What Is It?

Flores Insurance Agency is your friendly neighborhood insurance broker and notary public located right in the vibrant heart of Longmont, Colorado. Since 2014, they've been dedicated to providing a full range of insurance products—automotive, home, business, and more—tailored to suit the unique needs of the community. Whether you need help with general liability or a life insurance policy, they’ve got you covered.

The Experience

Walking into Flores Insurance Agency, you instantly feel at ease. The warm smiles and inviting atmosphere set a friendly tone right away. The team is genuinely eager to assist you in finding the best insurance options tailored to your needs. You might notice how every visitor seems to be treated like family, with the staff taking time to walk you through every question and concern, ensuring you understand the ins and outs of your policies.

While sitting down with your insurance agent, you find yourself impressed by their extensive knowledge. They expertly lay out your options, patiently addressing each of your questions. It’s clear that they’re not just there to sell you something; they’re invested in making sure you feel confident about your coverage decisions. It’s almost like you’re sharing a cup of coffee with a friend rather than discussing policies.

As the conversation flows, you can’t help but appreciate the sense of urgency they show in making sure you get the right coverage. There’s this genuine kindness that radiates from the team, and it makes the sometimes daunting process of selecting insurance feel much more manageable. You leave with a smile, knowing you’ve made an informed choice backed by the personal touch that Flores Insurance Agency promises.

Need a notary public to handle some legal documents? No problem! They offer those services too, so it’s a one-stop shop for all your needs. You’re already looking forward to sharing this experience with friends and family, since it's so refreshing to find a place committed to professionalism and customer care.

5

Frank Flores - State Farm Insurance Agent

195 S Main St Unit 5

Longmont, CO 80501

(303) 776-3926

Pros and Cons

  • Exceptional customer service with a friendly atmosphere.

  • Knowledgeable staff who genuinely care about clients' needs.

  • Quick response times and personalized assistance.

  • Helpful tips that can save clients money.

  • Occasionally slower response times during busy periods.

  • Some complex insurance topics might need clearer explanations.

What Is It?

Frank Flores - State Farm Insurance Agent is a highly regarded insurance agency located right in Longmont, CO. This team is dedicated to helping customers manage their insurance needs, ensuring they feel secure and protected. With a focus on excellent customer service and personalized care, they strive to create a welcoming environment for everyone who walks through their doors.

The Experience

Walking into Frank Flores - State Farm Insurance Agent is like stepping into a warm embrace. Right from the start, the friendly atmosphere sets the tone. You're greeted with genuine smiles and a willingness to help. As you sit down with one of the team members, you quickly realize they're not just ticking boxes—they're genuinely invested in your insurance journey. One visit might find you chatting with someone who is not only knowledgeable but also brings a positive energy that instantly reassures you. They take the time to explain your options clearly, making sure you feel confident about every decision.

Imagine you're trying to navigate the world of insurance, feeling a bit overwhelmed with all the jargon and options out there. But as you talk through your needs, the staff patiently walks you through everything. You can't help but appreciate their efforts when they share tips that could save you money. This isn't just a transaction; it's a partnership, with a clear focus on your best interests. Guests rave about how the staff goes the extra mile to ensure that every detail is covered, whether it's a question about policy specifics or navigating recent changes in coverage.

Your experience feels even more delightful when you see how quickly they respond to inquiries. Whether you're on the phone or visiting in person, it’s clear that they're committed to being there for you. You leave the office feeling a weight lifted, knowing you’re in good hands. Patrons often speak highly of how the staff is always ready to assist, turning potentially stressful moments into seamless, friendly experiences. It's this thoughtful approach that keeps clients coming back for more and referring their friends.

And, if you thought that was the end of it, you may also get the chance to meet other wonderful team members who bring their own flair to customer service. The ongoing support from the group is palpable, with everyone working harmoniously to ensure you’re taken care of. As you walk out, you're not just a client; you feel like part of a caring family eager to help you mitigate risks and plan for your future. There’s a certain joy in knowing that no matter what you face, this team has your back.

6

Mountain Insurance: Longmont

2362 Eagleview Cir

Longmont, CO 80504

(303) 808-9351

Pros and Cons

  • Highly knowledgeable and responsive staff.

  • Wide range of insurance options including personal and commercial.

  • Great at explaining complex insurance details.

  • Strong advocacy during claims process.

  • Genuine care for customer needs.

  • Some delays in email and call responses during busy times.

  • Complexity of insurance jargon can be overwhelming at times.

  • Occasional differences in pricing compared to market rates.

What Is It?

Mountain Insurance: Longmont is a dedicated independent insurance agency that focuses on providing comprehensive and affordable insurance solutions tailored for small and mid-sized businesses. With a commitment to exceptional customer service, they strive to simplify the complex world of insurance and guide clients toward the best options without any confusing jargon or high-pressure sales tactics. Their experienced agents work hard to find competitive rates, ensuring clients are protected with the most suitable coverage.

The Experience

Stepping into Mountain Insurance: Longmont feels like finding that reliable friend who always has your back. The moment you walk through their door or give them a call, you're welcomed with friendly faces that are eager to help. You might find yourself chatting with an agent who quickly understands your insurance needs, whether it’s for your home, car, or business. They’re not just checking boxes; they're genuinely invested in your peace of mind. From a simple auto policy to complex commercial insurance queries, you'll feel reassured by the expert guidance from representatives like Steve and Gail, who consistently communicate effectively to clarify any confusion.

As you share your unique situation, the agents impress you with their extensive knowledge and swift responses. Imagine walking out knowing that you’ve been given multiple options, each tailored to fit your budget and coverage needs. You could lean on them for anything from life insurance to event coverage, and they approach every request with the same friendliness and professionalism. It’s no wonder that many guests mention how they've saved a significant amount by choosing the right plans, a testament to the insightful recommendations provided.

Navigating through the often bewildering world of insurance isn't something most people look forward to, but with Mountain Insurance’s patient and attentive staff, it can almost become enjoyable. They don't just throw policies your way; they take the time to explain the ins and outs, helping you understand the details that matter most. You might even feel like you've gained a mini education on insurance by the time you finalize your policy!

Additionally, many patrons highlight the follow-up service they receive. Even after securing your policy, the team remains available to assist with questions or changes down the line, proving they’re partners in your ongoing insurance journey. And when it comes to claims or adjustments, they won't leave you stranded; they’re known to jump in and advocate on your behalf.

At your next visit or call with Mountain Insurance, you might walk away feeling not only taken care of but also part of a supportive community that advocates for your needs.

7

Rocky Mountain Insurance Center

338 Main St Ste. A

Longmont, CO 80501

(720) 442-0051

Pros and Cons

  • Personalized service that focuses on individual needs.

  • Friendly and welcoming atmosphere that eases insurance concerns.

  • Staff is patient, knowledgeable, and ready to answer all questions.

  • Customers leave feeling confident about their insurance choices.

  • Can experience wait times during busier periods.

  • Some guests desire more transparency in finer policy details.

  • Advice may occasionally feel somewhat generalized.

What Is It?

Rocky Mountain Insurance Center is your friendly neighborhood insurance broker located in the heart of Longmont, CO. With a focus on developing strong relationships with clients, they help you navigate the often tricky waters of insurance, ensuring you find the right coverage at the right price. They're independent, meaning they work for you and not the insurance carriers, striving to provide personalized service that fits your needs.

The Experience

Walking into Rocky Mountain Insurance Center feels like stepping into a world where your unique needs take center stage. Right away, you notice that this isn’t just about the numbers; it’s about a genuine partnership. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it easy to feel comfortable discussing your insurance needs. You’re greeted with smiles and a willingness to help that instantly puts any of your insurance worries at ease.

As you settle in, the staff takes the time to get to know you and your situation, rather than just pushing policies at you. You might find yourself having a detailed conversation about what options are available, perhaps while sipping on some hot coffee, as they patiently break down the differences among various insurance plans. Instead of feeling overwhelmed, you feel empowered as they explain which policies would suit you best and help you save money at the same time.

Picture this: after a thorough evaluation of your life situations, such as your home, car, or family, they generate a range of coverage options tailored to your specific needs. You’re encouraged to ask questions, and they answer each one with care and clarity, turning a typically confusing experience into the easiest time you’ve ever had shopping for insurance. And when you finally settle on a plan, you leave feeling happy and confident that you made the right choices for you.

Time after time, patrons reminisce about how seamless and enjoyable the experience is. Their positive rapport with the staff leaves a lasting impression, and you’re sure to walk out not only with the coverage you need but also with a trusting relationship for the future. Few things beat the peace of mind that comes from knowing you’re in good hands with Rocky Mountain Insurance Center.

The Glorious Places logo.
Raising up exceptional local businesses.
Made in Fort Collins, Colorado
Copyright © 2024 Glorious Places. All rights reserved.