9 Hearty Italian Restaurants in Sonoma County, CA
Last updated in October 2024
Sonoma County isn’t just about breathtaking vineyards and rolling hills; it's also home to some of the coziest Italian restaurants around. Picture yourself enjoying a hearty plate of homemade pasta after a day of exploring. Whether you’re seeking a family-style feast or a romantic dinner, these local gems have something special to offer. For instance, Ca'Bianca in Santa Rosa gives off that charming Victorian vibe while serving up to-die-for seafood and pasta in a delightful outdoor setting. Or check out Catelli's in Geyserville, where their infamous 10-layer lasagna is practically a rite of passage for any Italian food lover!
Baci | Cafe & Wine Bar
Baci Cafe & Wine Bar, located in Healdsburg, CA, is an authentic Italian restaurant that prides itself on offering exceptional dining experiences. The restaurant features a warm ambiance, friendly staff, and a menu filled with delicious Italian classics, from homemade pastas to delightful seafood dishes. Local favorites like the lobster ravioli and the burrata appetizer have garnered much love from regulars. Baci is a perfect spot for special occasions or a casual night out with family and friends, consistently wowing diners with both the food and the service.
What People Love
Incredible food that leaves diners raving, especially about the pasta and seafood dishes.
Friendly and attentive staff provide excellent service, making every visit enjoyable.
The warm atmosphere and welcoming owners create a lovely dining experience for all.
Generous portion sizes and high-quality ingredients are consistently highlighted by customers.
A great wine selection complements the menu, enhancing the dining experience.
What People Don't Like
-
The restaurant can get quite noisy, especially when busy, making it hard to have conversations.
-
Pricing is seen as a bit high, especially for the take-out options versus dining in.
You Have to Try
-
The lobster ravioli is frequently mentioned as a standout dish that’s a must-try.
-
The bucatini all amatriciana has received praise for its perfect flavors and portion size.
-
Their burrata appetizer proves to be a crowd favorite, setting a delightful tone for the meal.
-
Several diners recommend the risotto and various pasta dishes, noting their incredible flavor and quality.
-
Don’t skip the tiramisu for dessert; it’s often referred to as an absolute must-have at the end of your meal.
Bistro Don Giovanni
Bistro Don Giovanni is a beloved Italian restaurant located in Napa, CA, known for its delightful ambiance and delicious cuisine. With both indoor and outdoor dining options, it provides a charming setting ideal for romantic dinners or casual family gatherings. The restaurant features an impressive menu that showcases fresh, homemade pasta and various traditional Italian dishes, alongside an extensive wine list. Patrons also enjoy the warm and inviting service, making it a favorite spot for both locals and visitors in the Napa Valley.
What People Love
Charming outdoor patio with lovely fountain ambiance, perfect for dining on warm Napa nights.
Delicious menu featuring standout dishes like lemon cream ravioli, tiramisu, and the lamb shank.
Friendly and attentive staff who provide excellent service, making dining experiences enjoyable.
A great selection of wines to complement meals, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Fresh, homemade pasta that receives high praise from patrons.
What People Don't Like
-
Service can be inconsistent, with some patrons experiencing long waits and disorganization during busy times.
-
A few dishes have received criticism for being bland or not meeting expectations given the price.
You Have to Try
-
The lemon cream ravioli is a crowd favorite that many rave about as a must-have.
-
Tiramisu is often highlighted as the perfect way to end a meal, with its delightful flavor.
-
The lamb shank is praised for being tender and flavorful, making it a popular choice among guests.
-
Don't miss out on the outdoor seating—the atmosphere by the fountain is said to be enchanting, especially at night.
Bricco Osteria & Bar
Bricco Osteria & Bar is a delightful family-owned Italian restaurant located in beautiful Calistoga, California. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, this gem serves up authentic Italian cuisine that boasts fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for a delightful seafood pasta or a classically prepared lasagna, Bricco Osteria aims to provide a memorable dining experience for everyone, making it a perfect spot for a romantic evening or a fun gathering with friends.
What People Love
Delicious food made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
Friendly and attentive staff that create a welcoming atmosphere.
The owner is charming and often engages with diners.
Great value for quality food in an area of high-priced dining options.
Bull out a lovely atmosphere, perfect for various dining experiences like romantic dinners or family gatherings.
What People Don't Like
-
Service can be a bit slow during busy times.
-
Some dishes may not meet expectations based on price.
You Have to Try
-
Calamari Fritti, perfectly fried and served with a tasty dipping sauce.
-
Mom's Lasagna, a rich and hearty dish that keeps guests coming back for more.
-
Chicken Parmigiana, often rated as the best people have ever had.
-
Tiramisu, described as light, fluffy, and bursting with flavor.
Ca'Bianca
Located in the heart of Santa Rosa, Ca'Bianca is a stunning Italian restaurant that beautifully combines charm and flavor. Housed in a lovely Victorian home, its inviting ambiance is perfect for any occasion, from cozy dinners to large family celebrations. The menu showcases a blend of regional Italian cuisines, featuring house-made pasta, perfectly cooked steaks, fresh seafood, and delightful desserts. With a lovely outdoor seating area filled with flowers and twinkling lights, it's a picturesque spot for a memorable dining experience.
What People Love
Charming atmosphere, especially the beautiful outdoor garden seating.
High-quality food with an authentic Italian feel, including house-made pasta and fresh seafood dishes.
Friendly and attentive service that creates a welcoming dining experience.
Perfect for special occasions, whether it's a romantic date night or family gatherings.
A delightful selection of cocktails and an extensive wine list to complement the meal.
What People Don't Like
-
Inconsistent service; some guests experienced slow service or disorganization during busy times.
-
Limited parking options in a bustling area; finding a spot can be a challenge.
You Have to Try
-
The butternut squash ravioli, known for its rich flavors and perfect texture.
-
Vongole linguine is a must for seafood lovers; the clams are fresh and flavorful in a delightful sauce.
-
The famed tiramisu which is praised for its balance and rich creaminess.
-
The Carbonara, a favorite among many diners, offering a classic Italian experience.
-
The grilled salmon, which has garnered rave reviews for its preparation and taste.
Cafe Citti
Cafe Citti is a charming little Italian spot located in Santa Rosa, California, where locals gather for a taste of authentic Italian cuisine. Known for their inviting ambiance with both indoor and outdoor seating, the restaurant offers a delightful array of dishes, from fresh handmade pastas to savory sauces crafted with care. Their outdoor seating, complete with heaters for cooler evenings, creates a cozy atmosphere perfect for any occasion. Plus, with options for takeout now available, enjoying a delicious meal from Cafe Citti is easier than ever!
What People Love
Delicious homemade pasta dishes, especially the gnocchi and ravioli.
Friendly and welcoming staff that provide great service.
Charming outdoor seating area, perfect for a relaxed dining experience.
Tasty and generous portions coupled with reasonable prices for quality Italian food.
Consistently high-quality dishes that feel authentic and comforting.
What People Don't Like
-
Some diners mention that pricing can be a bit on the higher side, which may deter frequent visits.
-
Insects can be a nuisance in the outdoor seating area, impacting the dining experience.
You Have to Try
-
The Gnocchi with Citti sauce is a must; it's described as melt-in-your-mouth!
-
The creamy pesto gnocchi keeps popping up as a favorite among frequent patrons.
-
For something heavier, the lasagna has a loyal fan base, though opinions vary.
-
If you're in the mood for something unique, try their homemade tiramisu for a sweet ending!
-
The calamari is noted for being a standout appetizer, prepared in a way that delights newcomers.
Catelli's Restaurant
Catelli's Restaurant has been serving up delectable Italian cuisine in Geyserville for years, earning a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. Known for its charming atmosphere and family-style service, this eatery prides itself on using locally sourced ingredients to create mouthwatering dishes. The standout 10-layer lasagna and various pasta options have received special attention, making it a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy authentic Italian fare.
What People Love
Delicious homemade pasta and classic Italian dishes that keep guests coming back for more.
A beautiful outdoor patio that enhances the dining experience, especially on warmer nights.
Friendly and attentive staff providing great service to ensure an enjoyable visit.
The 10-layer lasagna is a standout favorite, often described as the best in the area.
A cozy, welcoming atmosphere that’s perfect for family gatherings or special occasions.
What People Don't Like
-
Some guests have mentioned inconsistent service, especially during busy times, which can affect their overall experience.
-
Limited parking can be challenging, particularly during peak hours.
You Have to Try
-
The 10-layer lasagna, touted as one of the best around, is a must-order and has become a signature dish.
-
Meatball sliders, which are consistently praised as flavorful and satisfying appetizers.
-
Mushroom cream sauce pasta, noted for being rich and creamy, is a crowd favorite.
-
The garlic bread, often described as the perfect starter, deserves a spot on your table.
-
The burrata appetizer, an ideal way to start your meal, is both fresh and delicious.
Cucina Paradiso
Cucina Paradiso is a delightful trattoria in downtown Petaluma, offering an extensive menu of traditional Italian dishes, from classic pastas to hearty mains. The restaurant prides itself on its warm ambiance and attentive service, creating an inviting atmosphere for both special occasions and casual dinners. Diners can enjoy their meals on a charming patio overlooking the river, making it a perfect spot for enjoying Petaluma's scenic views while savoring authentic Italian cuisine.
What People Love
Authentic and delicious Italian food with fresh ingredients.
Charming atmosphere with classic Italian decor.
Friendly and attentive service, especially from staff members.
Great selection of wines that complement the meals.
Lovely outdoor seating by the river, perfect for al fresco dining.
What People Don't Like
-
Service can be inconsistent during busy times, leading to longer waits.
-
Some dishes didn't meet expectations in terms of flavor or preparation.
You Have to Try
-
Homemade gnocchi, known for being rich and flavorful.
-
Ravioli, particularly the duck filling, which is a fan favorite.
-
Bruschetta as a delicious appetizer that many recommend.
-
Spaghetti alle vongole, a standout seafood pasta dish.
-
Tiramisu for dessert, often highlighted for its taste.
Riviera Ristorante
Riviera Ristorante is a beloved family-run Italian restaurant located in Santa Rosa, known for its authentic flavors and vibrant cycling-themed decor. With a menu packed full of cherished Italian dishes, it's the perfect spot for everything from casual lunches to romantic dinners. Diners rave about the homemade pasta and fresh seafood, and many return regularly to enjoy the warm, inviting atmosphere and attentive service. The outdoor patio is an especially popular spot, offering a charming setting to savor delicious meals.
What People Love
Authentic Italian cuisine that transports diners straight to Italy.
Warm, friendly service that makes you feel like family.
A cozy outdoor seating area that's perfect for a romantic dinner.
A great variety of delicious pastas and seafood dishes.
Weekly specials that always impress with unique flavors.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasionally slow service during busy times.
-
Ambiance could use a cozy touch; some find it a bit stark.
You Have to Try
-
The lasagna, praised for its flavorful layers and hearty portions.
-
Carbonara that's recognized for being creamy and satisfying; a definite must.
-
Seafood specials like the lobster risotto that have received rave reviews.
-
Ravioli dishes, particularly those with unique fillings like rabbit and mushrooms.
-
Unique appetizers like calamari salad and bruschetta made with fresh ingredients.
Trattoria Cattaneo
Located at 2700 Yulupa Ave in Santa Rosa, Trattoria Cattaneo is a charming, family-owned Italian restaurant that prides itself on its traditional, homemade dishes. Every bite reflects love and care, and the welcoming atmosphere feels just like dining at grandma's house. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Sonoma County, this restaurant offers a delightful dining experience filled with authentic flavors and a warm touch from the genuinely friendly staff.
What People Love
Warm, family-oriented atmosphere that makes you feel like part of the family.
Authentic Italian dishes that transport you straight to Italy.
Friendly and supportive staff who provide excellent service.
Generous portions of food that ensure you won't leave hungry.
Homemade desserts that are a must-try, especially the tiramisu.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasional inconsistency in food quality, leading to a few disappointing dishes.
-
Some diners noted that specific items like the bread or take-out meals underwhelmed compared to in-house dining.
You Have to Try
-
The lasagna, absolutely loved for its rich flavors and generous portions.
-
Chicken Parmesan that's reminiscent of a comforting home-cooked meal.
-
Gnocchi that's been described as cloud-like and deliciously prepared.
-
Tiramisu and other homemade desserts that delight sweet lovers.
-
Focaccia served with a delectable olive-walnut tapenade, a perfect starter!
