9 Fantastic Pizza Restaurants in Sonoma County, CA
Last updated in October 2024
Sonoma County's pizza scene is as diverse as its breathtaking landscapes, and if you're in the mood for a slice (or two), you're in for a treat! From the cozy vibes of Gio's Pizza in Santa Rosa, serving up everything from hearty slices to fresh salads, to Old Chicago's deep-dish delights right in Petaluma, there’s a pie for every palate. Whether you’re catching up with friends or grabbing a quick bite after a wine tour, these places have got the warm, inviting atmosphere you crave as well as delicious food that keeps visitors coming back. And let’s not forget about the artisanal offerings! Diavola in Geyserville is not just about pizza; it’s a whole experience with its wood-fired creations and seasonal ingredients. Or if you’re on a quest for something unique, Mama J's Pizzeria in Penngrove boasts West Coast-style pies that are known for their incredible flavor. With so many local gems, you're bound to find your new favorite slice here!
Croccante Artisan Pizza
Croccante Artisan Pizza is a charming family-owned spot located on Pearl St in Napa, known for its mouthwatering Detroit-style pizza. With a commitment to fresh ingredients and exceptional service, this restaurant creates a welcoming environment perfect for gatherings or casual outings. The menu features a delightful selection of pizzas, salads, and delicious appetizers, ensuring there's something for everyone. Whether you’re popping in for a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely meal with friends and family, Croccante offers a memorable dining experience.
What People Love
Family-owned atmosphere that makes everyone feel welcome.
Excellent service with attentive staff.
Detroit-style pizza with a unique and delicious twist.
Fresh ingredients creating bold and flavorful dishes.
Casual, laid-back vibe perfect for enjoying with friends and family.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasionally, there can be hiccups with takeout orders that require some follow-up.
You Have to Try
-
Detroit-style pizza, especially the Burrata and Roasted Potato & Pancetta varieties.
-
Garlic knots that are a crowd favorite for their amazing taste.
-
The Caesar salad, often praised for its dressing.
-
Meatballs, which complement the pizza perfectly.
Diavola Pizzeria & Salumeria
Diavola Pizzeria & Salumeria is a beloved restaurant in Geyserville, CA, known for its outstanding wood-fired pizzas and creative Italian dishes. Set in a charming location with a rustic vibe, it offers both indoor and delightful outdoor dining options. With a menu that features seasonal ingredients, guests can expect fresh flavors every time they visit. Whether you're stopping in during a wine tour or just looking for a cozy dining experience, Diavola provides a taste of Italy that locals and visitors alike rave about.
What People Love
Incredible wood-fired pizzas that are consistently praised for their quality and flavor.
A friendly and attentive staff that enhances the dining experience.
Charming ambiance, especially the outdoor patio, perfect for enjoying meals in a relaxed setting.
Diverse menu offerings featuring unique and seasonal dishes, ensuring there's always something new to try.
Great option for those needing gluten-free pizza, with many praising its quality.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasional slow service during busy times, which can be frustrating for diners.
-
Pricey menu items, making it a bit of a splurge for families or larger groups.
You Have to Try
-
The Dictator pizza, featuring a unique combination of marinated short rib and spicy elements that many rave about.
-
Margarita pizza, praised for its authenticity and flavor, making it a classic must-have.
-
The seasonal beet salad that pairs well with many pizzas.
-
Gnocchi, frequently highlighted as a standout dish with incredible flavors.
-
The signature truffle pecorino dish, which has received enthusiastic feedback for its taste.
Gio's Pizza
Gio's Pizza is a popular pizzeria located in Santa Rosa, California, known for serving up some of the best pizza in the North Bay. This friendly neighborhood spot prides itself on using fresh, quality ingredients to create a diverse menu that includes not just pizza but also pasta, subs, and salads. With generous portion sizes and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s the perfect place for a casual meal with family or friends. Whether you're in the mood for takeout or dining in, Gio's has got you covered!
What People Love
Delicious pizza with high-quality ingredients and a wide range of flavors.
Friendly and welcoming staff that create a family-like atmosphere.
Generous portion sizes, especially the huge pizza slices.
Specialty options like gluten-free crusts and unique pizza varieties.
Great local spot suitable for families, quick takeout, or casual dining.
What People Don't Like
-
Service can be a bit slow during peak times.
-
Some patrons feel the pizza is overly priced compared to quality.
You Have to Try
-
Mac & Cheese Pizza: A crowd favorite that's truly unique and hearty!
-
Pesto Bread Sticks: Perfectly cheesy and loved by many, great as a side or snack!
-
Kimo's Hawaiian Pizza: This one comes with bacon bits - a delicious twist on a classic!
-
Trinchini Pizza: A local favorite that's always highly recommended for its incredible flavor!
-
Gluten-Free Options: They have some of the best gluten-free pizza crusts around!
Huria's Woodfired Pizza & Catering
Huria's Woodfired Pizza & Catering is a delightful mobile eatery based in Bodega Bay, specializing in artisanal wood-fired pizzas that beautifully blend Mediterranean influences with classic New York styles. Owned and operated by a charming husband and wife team, this local spot has become a treasured choice for both casual meals and special events, including weddings. With an emphasis on using high-quality ingredients, their offerings not only promise fantastic flavors but also create an inviting atmosphere for all their patrons. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or catering an elegant gathering, Huria’s is sure to impress!
What People Love
Delicious wood-fired pizza that combines Neapolitan and New York styles.
Exceptional, friendly service from the husband/wife team running the business.
Perfect for catering special events with rave reviews from wedding guests.
High-quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations in their pizzas.
Convenient pickup service, allowing for easy pizza nights.
What People Don't Like
-
Some customers express a desire for greater pizza customization options.
-
A few mention that the pricing may feel a bit steep for the portion sizes.
You Have to Try
-
The Grandma pizza, a favorite that blends traditional flavors with unique twists.
-
The smoked hummus, often described as world-class and a must-have side.
-
The Brooklyn pizza, which consistently gets high marks for its flavor and quality.
-
The beet salad, known for its freshness and standout taste.
-
Any of their gourmet dessert options, especially the chocolate cake with sea salt caramel whipped cream.
Mama J's Pizzeria
Mama J's Pizzeria in Penngrove is a beloved local eatery that has made a name for itself with its mouth-watering West Coast style pizza and other delicious offerings such as hearty salads and even oven-baked ribs. With a friendly vibe and a menu boasting a variety of flavors, it's a fantastic spot for families and friends alike. The pizzeria prides itself on fresh ingredients and has become a staple in the community, perfect for grabbing a bite or enjoying a casual meal out.
What People Love
Delicious pizza with generous toppings and flavorful sauces.
Friendly and welcoming staff that create a pleasant atmosphere.
Great options for both dine-in and takeout, with family-friendly seating.
Freshly made pizza dough and a variety of crust choices like sourdough and cauliflower.
Noteworthy appetizers like mozzarella sticks and large salads.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasional issues with inconsistent pizza quality or overcooking.
-
Service can be hit-or-miss, particularly during busy times.
You Have to Try
-
The signature Nona Maria pizza loaded with toppings.
-
The 49er pizza on sourdough crust, a customer favorite.
-
Try the BBQ sauce ham onion and pineapple pizza, loved by many.
-
Don't miss the crispy and flavorful mozzarella sticks as an appetizer.
-
The Greek salad is perfect for a light, crunchy option.
Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant
Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant in downtown Petaluma is a beloved pizza spot that's been serving up their famous Chicago-style deep dish pizza for over 30 years. Whether you're dining in or picking up, you can expect hearty portions and a menu loaded with a variety of toppings and crust options, including gluten-free. It's a family-friendly venue perfect for gatherings, and the historic setting adds to the charm as you tuck into a delicious slice while enjoying the view of the bustling streets below.
What People Love
Delicious deep dish pizza that's often compared to the best in Chicago.
Friendly and attentive service that makes you feel welcome.
A long-standing favorite in Petaluma with loyal customers who have been visiting for decades.
Family-friendly atmosphere with options for large groups or special celebrations.
Great selection of toppings and crust options, including gluten-free.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasionally long wait times for food, especially during busy hours.
-
Some issues with pizza being overcooked or not prepared as expected.
You Have to Try
-
The classic deep dish pizza, especially with the double crust option.
-
Garlic pesto bread on the side—a delicious appetizer.
-
The house salad, often paired with pizza, has received high praise.
-
Their famous ranch dressing, especially with the cheesy garlic bread.
Pizzaleah
Pizzaleah is a highly regarded pizzeria located in Windsor, CA, known for its handcrafted, artisan brick oven pizzas. The menu features a variety of delicious options, including salads, meatballs, calzones, and garlic knots, all made with local, quality ingredients. It's a warm and friendly place, perfect for gathering with friends or family to enjoy uniquely flavored pies. With a focus on quality and creative combinations, Pizzaleah has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
What People Love
Delicious and unique flavor combinations that impress both pizza lovers and newcomers.
Thin, crispy crusts that are perfectly cooked, often described as some of the best around.
Friendly and attentive staff, providing great service that enhances the dining experience.
A casual yet welcoming atmosphere that makes it a fun place for families and friends to gather.
Quality ingredients, including locally sourced toppings, elevating the overall pizza experience.
What People Don't Like
-
Some find the pricing a bit high compared to other pizza places, which can be a consideration for budget-conscious diners.
-
Occasional long wait times during peak hours can be frustrating for those eager to dig into their meal.
You Have to Try
-
The Old Grey Beard pizza, known for its amazing blend of flavors, including Calabrian peppers and hot honey.
-
Garlic knots, often highlighted as a must-have appetizer that complements the pizza perfectly.
-
The Mush-a-Roni pizza, which has earned awards for its delicious flavor and well-balanced toppings.
-
The Po-Tay-To pizza, a crowd favorite with its unique take on a classic flavor profile.
Sonoma Pizza Co.
Sonoma Pizza Co. is a delightful artisan pizzeria in Forestville, perfect for those seeking a fresh, local dining experience. Situated in the beautiful Sonoma wine country, they serve an array of hand-crafted pizzas, including wood-fired Neapolitan and unique creations like the Pepperoni Nirvana. Every bite reflects their commitment to quality, with locally sourced ingredients making up their seasonal menu. You can enjoy meals in their nature-inspired outdoor terrace or take advantage of convenient takeout options. Plus, with a variety of gluten-free and vegan choices, there's something for everyone!
What People Love
Incredible wood-fired pizzas with unique flavor combinations.
Friendly and attentive staff creating a welcoming atmosphere.
Beautiful outdoor dining space, perfect for enjoying meals.
Excellent gluten-free and vegan options available.
Fresh ingredients sourced locally, enhancing quality.
What People Don't Like
-
Some find the pricing a bit on the higher side for the portion sizes.
You Have to Try
-
The Pepperoni Nirvana with burrata and hot honey—it’s a fan favorite!
-
The garlic bread, described as both flavorful and addictive.
-
The signature Burrata and Beets salad, a must for fresh flavor lovers.
-
Their mushroom pizzas, particularly the Mushroom Mycopia, offer delightful depth of flavor.
Stonework Pizza & Tap
Stonework Pizza & Tap is a must-visit eatery in Petaluma that brings gourmet stone-fired pizzas to the forefront, all while showcasing a solid selection of over 20 local Sonoma breweries and wines. With its cozy environment, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience for families, friends, and pizza lovers alike. Whether you're digging into a mouthwatering pie or enjoying happy hour specials, the friendly staff and quality ingredients ensure you'll leave satisfied.
What People Love
Gourmet stone-fired pizzas crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
A fantastic selection of local Sonoma County craft beers and wines.
Family-friendly atmosphere that welcomes kids with dietary options.
Great happy hour deals that make for a fun gathering spot.
Friendly and attentive service that makes you feel at home.
What People Don't Like
-
Some diners find the crust to be a bit too thick or the pizzas lacking in toppings.
-
A few mention occasional service issues like delays or cleanliness concerns.
You Have to Try
-
The Chicken Tikka Masala pizza for a unique flavor twist.
-
Garlic knots, which are a favorite starter and often praised for their taste.
-
The Hawaiian pizza featuring pulled pork instead of traditional Canadian bacon.
-
The gluten-free cauliflower crust pizza that's surprisingly delicious.
