14 Tasty Ice Cream Shops in Chicago, IL

Some complaints about the limited indoor seating, which can feel cramped, especially during busy times.

A few feel the prices are a bit high for the portion sizes offered.

Goat Cheese Cashew Caramel, often described as a standout and must-try flavor that's rich and inventive.

Malted Vanilla Pretzel, a unique take on classic flavors that combines sweetness with a bit of crunch.

Espresso Chip, which lovers say packs a delicious coffee punch perfect for those coffee aficionados.

Strawberry Balsamic, an unusual yet flavorful combination that's become a favorite.

Dulce de Leche Cheesecake Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies, often highlighted as an outstanding item that pairs perfectly with their gelato.

Some complaints about the scoops being a bit on the smaller side compared to the high price point.

A few negative experiences with customer service that detracted from the overall enjoyment.

Gooey Butter Cake flavor, a favorite among many for its delightful texture and sweetness.

Brambleberry Crisp, known for its rich flavor and unique components that complement the ice cream well.

Wildberry Lavender, loved for its light and refreshing taste.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, which combines two crowd-pleasers for a creamy delight.

The freshly made waffle cones, which come with a tantalizing aroma as you enter the shop.

Long wait times, especially during peak hours, can be a downside for some.

Occasional service issues, where orders may not be accurate or timely.

Mango Tango – a fan favorite that captures the refreshing taste of mango perfectly.

Oreo Secret – a rich and creamy delight that's a hit with both kids and adults.

Double Trouble – where chocolate lovers can indulge in an extra thick ice cream experience.

Green Matcha – a smoother, more refined choice that's both unique and flavorful.

Key Lime Pie with fruity pebbles – a fun twist on a classic dessert that’s hard to resist.

At times, the service can be slow, especially when it's busy, leading to mix-ups with orders.

The OMG concrete, a delicious mix of peanut butter, fudge brownies, and custard that has patrons raving.

Seasonal specialties that rotate regularly, offering always something new.

The classic banana split, a hit among families and ice cream lovers alike.

Baked goods like cupcakes, particularly the carrot cake, which is a standout.

The unique candy selection, including rare finds that evoke nostalgia.

A few customers mentioned the absence of sit-down options, which can make enjoying your treat a bit tricky.

Some patrons noted that dessert portions melted quickly under certain conditions. They also suggested the shop have better signage to help navigate flavor options.

Graham Central Station flavor – described as incredible and a must-try by several fans.

The Blue Panda ice cream – noted for its unique cookie flavor.

Refreshing banana splits that are popular among families.

Brownies a la mode – highly appreciated as a delicious complement to the ice cream.

Hot chocolate bombs – gained popularity as a fun and tasty treat.

Some customers mention high prices for ice cream compared to non-vegan options.

Occasionally, limited flavors available during busier hours.

The ube ice cream, known for its caramelly and nutty flavor, is a standout favorite.

Mint chocolate chip is praised for its delicate yet rich taste.

Strawberry ice cream made from organic strawberries without a hint of coconut flavor is highly recommended.

The delicious gluten-free and vegan pastries, especially the donuts, are a must-try.

Some customers have experienced inconsistent flavor quality or service on occasion.

Mango and coconut combo – a refreshing must-have on a hot day!

The horchata Italian ice is a fan favorite, offering a sweet and creamy twist.

Lemon ice that really packs a citrus punch – perfect on warm summer nights!

Seasonal flavors like guava and passion fruit that rotate throughout the summer.

Some find the prices to be on the higher side compared to other ice cream shops in Chicago.

The small size of the shop can lead to slow service, especially with many flavor samples.

The pistachio gelato, celebrated for its true pistachio flavor and creaminess.

The Trio, a favorite among many for its fantastic combination of flavors.

Burnt butter vanilla, noted for its unique taste and texture.

Vegan options like vegan almond and the mango lassi, which surprised many with their deliciousness.

Hot chocolate, a must-try according to those who have enjoyed it.

Prices can be pricey for the size of the treats.

Some found certain items could be better in texture or quality.

Peanut Butter Potato Chip bar - an excellent mix of salty and sweet.

Horchata Crunch bar - creamy and intensely flavored.

Birthday Cake pop - a delightful nostalgic treat.

Key Lime Pie bar - praised for its refreshing taste.

Coffee Pretzel Toffee bar - a unique twist that’s hard to beat.

Some occasional difficulties with food quality, especially specific items like the chicken and sides.

A few comments about the shop being a bit hard to find or missing signage.

Banana pudding ice cream, known for its rich flavor that feels like a dessert in a scoop.

Strawberry cheesecake ice cream, which perfectly balances tartness and sweetness.

Peach cobbler ice cream, which captures that home-baked flavor everyone loves.

Sweet potato pie and key lime pie ice creams, both praised for their unique tastes and freshness.

For a refreshing treat, don't miss the Italian ice options.

Sometimes the service can be slow, resulting in longer wait times for ice cream.

Occasional issues with flavor availability, such as popular items running out unexpectedly.

Bourbon Butter Pecan – a fan favorite, loved for its rich flavor and creamy texture.

Banana Pudding Ice Cream – known for being exceptionally delicious and reminiscent of classic desserts.

Peach Cobbler paired with vanilla ice cream – a must-try combination that many rave about.

Honey Cinnamon Graham Cracker – a unique flavor that's consistently mentioned as a top choice.

Vegan Vanilla and Chocolate options – praised by those who appreciate a dairy-free treat that doesn’t compromise on flavor.

Some customers mention long wait times and understaffing during peak hours.

A few negative experiences regarding incorrect orders and lack of attention to detail.

The famous rainbow cone featuring layers of chocolate, strawberry, vanilla with nuts, pistachio, and orange sherbet.

Pistachio ice cream which is often mentioned as a favorite.

Milkshakes that come highly recommended for their creamy texture.

House-made mini donuts that are fresh and a treat to enjoy (when available).

Sundaes that offer a delicious way to indulge in multiple flavors.

Some find the prices on the higher side, which can be a deterrent for regular visits.

A few customers feel misled by the name 'Creamery' and the absence of traditional dairy ingredients.

The sweet corn soft serve, a unique and crowd-pleasing flavor.

Waffle cones that have a hint of cinnamon and are highly praised.

Seasonal specialties like chocolate chai carrot cake swirl or pumpkin streusel.

The smores sundae that’s become a favorite for its decadent toppings.

The candy bar pie is also worth a try for dessert lovers.

Some found the prices a bit steep, especially given the small portion sizes.

A few mentioned that the flavors could be overwhelmingly sweet.

The Smores Sundae – a crowd favorite topped with toasted marshmallows.

The Candy Bar Sundae featuring miso caramel and a chocolate shell.

The unique lavender vanilla shake that's been a hit.

The homemade gluten-free waffle cones that add a delightful twist to any order.