11 Fabulous Sandwich Shops in Chicago, IL
Last updated in October 2024
When it comes to sandwiches in Chicago, you're in for a tasty treat! From cozy delis to gourmet hotspots, there’s no shortage of mouthwatering options. For instance, Genuine Sandwich Shop on Elston Ave is a neighborhood haven where you can grab a home-cooked meal, and its community vibe keeps patrons coming back for more. Over in Avondale, TriBecca’s is all about big flavors and quality ingredients, offering a variety of vegetarian options that ensure everyone’s cravings are satisfied. If you're in Uptown, North Buena Deli is your go-to for exceptional sandwiches, and did you know they also have an amazing selection of wines and craft beers? Talk about a perfect picnic combo! And then there's La Sandwichera Cafe in Humboldt Park, where you can enjoy some delicious panini-style sandwiches infused with Puerto Rican flavors. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing something on the go, each of these spots reflects Chicago’s love for good, hearty food.
All Too Well - Lincoln Park
All Too Well in Lincoln Park is a delightful gourmet sandwich shop known for its creative and delicious sandwiches. With a menu featuring unique combinations and fresh ingredients, it has quickly become a favorite for locals and visitors alike. Not only does it offer a cozy atmosphere perfect for a quick bite or takeout, but it also boasts friendly and attentive service. The shop is conveniently located near Lincoln Park, making it an ideal stop before enjoying a day outdoors.
What People Love
Unique and delicious sandwich combinations that cater to various tastes.
Fresh ingredients and high-quality bread that really elevate the flavors.
Quick service, even during busy hours, making it a great spot for a quick lunch.
A cozy, friendly vibe perfect for casual dining or takeout.
Gourmet quality at reasonable prices for the quality offered.
What People Don't Like
-
Some find the prices on the higher side, especially for a sandwich.
-
Occasional service hiccups with staff being busy or a lack of accommodations for modifications.
You Have to Try
-
The Oh Yeah! - praised as one of the best sandwiches ever eaten.
-
The Bombay Chulet - a delightful combo of turkey, prosciutto, and spicy fig jam, known for its unique flavor.
-
The T & Brie - described as one of the best deli sandwiches around, even reminiscent of Italy.
-
The Cousins Sandwich - a standout vegetarian option that shouldn't be missed.
-
The Tatanka - a juicy buffalo chicken sandwich that has left a lasting impression on repeat customers.
Bari Foods
Bari Foods is a beloved grocery store and butcher shop in Chicago, delivering an authentic Italian experience right in the heart of the city. Known for its remarkable selection of Italian products and freshly made sub sandwiches, Bari has been a staple in the community for decades. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Italian beef sandwich or looking to pick up some unique grocery items, Bari has you covered with quality and affordability.
What People Love
Incredible Italian beef and sub sandwiches.
Fantastic quality ingredients and fresh produce.
Great customer service and friendly staff.
A nostalgic, classic Italian deli experience.
A diverse selection of Italian groceries and specialties.
What People Don't Like
-
Wait times can sometimes be long, especially during peak hours.
-
Inconsistencies in orders and service quality.
You Have to Try
-
Italian beef sandwich with hot giardiniera.
-
Hearty meatball sub, packed with flavor.
-
Classic Italian sub, a must for any visitor.
-
Homemade giardiniera, perfect for adding spice to your meals.
-
Delicious baked goods from the adjacent bakery.
Bodega Bay Chicago
Bodega Bay Chicago is your new go-to spot for delicious breakfast bagel sandwiches, hearty deli subs, and a variety of other grocery essentials, all conveniently located in the bustling Wicker Park neighborhood. With a focus on fresh ingredients and friendly service, this charming shop offers a unique vibe that feels both casual and welcoming. Plus, it’s a fantastic place to pick up snacks, drinks, or some much-needed essentials after a day out in the neighborhood!
What People Love
Fresh and high-quality ingredients, particularly Boar's Head deli meats.
Friendly and welcoming staff that provide great service.
A diverse menu with popular options including breakfast burritos and deli sandwiches.
Convenient location with a good selection of snacks, drinks, and grocery essentials.
Overall clean, well-organized space with a nice atmosphere.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasional service issues that can disrupt the dining experience.
-
Some complaints about the portion sizes or pricing being higher than expected.
You Have to Try
-
Breakfast sandwich with bacon and sausage – a true crowd favorite!
-
The Italian sub has gained a lot of love from locals.
-
Caprese panini that many rave about for its flavor and freshness.
-
Breakfast burrito that keeps folks coming back for more!
-
Signature deli subs that stand out compared to typical chain options.
Fontano's Subs
Fontano's Subs is a beloved local deli in Chicago, offering hearty sub sandwiches crafted with quality ingredients. With a warm, casual atmosphere and a history stretching back to the 1930s, it's a go-to spot for both locals and visitors alike. Their menu features a variety of Italian subs, with generous serving sizes and options for every appetite. Conveniently located near UIC, it's a perfect pit stop for a delicious lunch!
What People Love
Delicious, fresh ingredients that make for fantastic subs.
The Blockbuster and Wise Guy sandwiches are especially popular and highly recommended.
Generous portion sizes that leave you satisfied without breaking the bank.
A warm, nostalgic atmosphere with a family-run vibe that keeps customers coming back.
Quick service, especially during busy times, making it a great spot for lunch.
What People Don't Like
-
Service can sometimes be hit-or-miss, with a few complaints about staff attitudes.
-
Parking can be tough, especially during peak lunch hours.
You Have to Try
-
The Blockbuster sub, often praised as the best in the city, is a must-try for any first-time visitor.
-
The Wise Guy sandwich packed with fresh toppings is another standout that's sure to impress.
-
Don’t skip the homemade giardiniera peppers – they add a delightful kick to any sandwich!
-
Their meatball sub has garnered rave reviews for its rich flavor and freshness.
J.T.'s Genuine Sandwich Shop
J.T. Genuine Sandwich Shop is a beloved neighborhood spot in Chicago, situated on Elston Ave. This family-friendly gem focuses on homemade snacks, soups, sandwiches, and salads, all crafted with care and attention to detail. With a cozy environment and a welcoming vibe, it’s the perfect place to grab a hearty meal, whether you’re dining in or taking away. The owner is involved in the community, truly making it feel like a local hangout that you’ll want to return to time and time again.
What People Love
Exceptional sandwiches made with high-quality ingredients.
Friendly staff who create a welcoming atmosphere.
Great value with generous portions for the price.
Cozy neighborhood vibe perfect for a casual meal.
A rotating selection of unique sandwiches and specials.'],'what_people_dont_like':['Some sandwiches can be a tad expensive.','Occasional concerns about specific food items being inconsistent.'],'you_have_to_try':['The Breaded Pork Tenderloin Sandwich—mentioned as a true standout.
The J.T.'s Special Burger, which combines beef with granny smith apple for a tasty twist.
Chili Cheese Fries, known for being both crispy and flavorful.
The Beans and Greens sandwich has earned its own fanbase for its hearty ingredients.'],'about':'J.T. Genuine Sandwich Shop is a beloved neighborhood spot in Chicago, situated on Elston Ave. This family-friendly gem focuses on homemade snacks, soups, sandwiches, and salads, all crafted with care and attention to detail. With a cozy environment and a welcoming vibe, it’s the perfect place to grab a hearty meal, whether you’re dining in or taking away. The owner is involved in the community, truly making it feel like a local hangout that you’ll want to return to time and time again.'} In this charm-filled spot, you’ll find delicious sandwiches that celebrate both classic flavors and innovative twists, all while enjoying a nice neighborhood atmosphere.
What People Don't Like
-
Some sandwiches can be a tad expensive.
-
Occasional concerns about specific food items being inconsistent.
You Have to Try
-
The Breaded Pork Tenderloin Sandwich—mentioned as a true standout.
-
The J.T.'s Special Burger, which combines beef with granny smith apple for a tasty twist.
-
Chili Cheese Fries, known for being both crispy and flavorful.
-
The Beans and Greens sandwich has earned its own fanbase for its hearty ingredients.
La Sandwichera Cafe
La Sandwichera Cafe is a cozy sandwich shop located in the heart of Humboldt Park, serving up delicious panini-style sandwiches and a variety of casual dining options. The café offers a friendly atmosphere perfect for grabbing a quick bite, enjoying a drink, or catching up with friends. With a menu that celebrates Puerto Rican flavors and quality ingredients, La Sandwichera has quickly become a local favorite for both breakfast and lunch.
What People Love
Great atmosphere with a laid-back vibe, perfect for a casual meal or a drink.
The sandwiches, especially the Chancleta and pastrami, are consistently praised for their flavor and quality.
The staff is super friendly and welcoming, making every visit feel special.
Locals recommend the coffee and breakfast options, such as the coconut oatmeal, as standout items too.
The place is kid-friendly, with options and accommodations for little ones.
What People Don't Like
-
Some customers have noted inconsistencies with service and order accuracy during peak times.
-
A few patrons have experienced issues with food quality under new management, which occasionally impacts the overall experience.
You Have to Try
-
The Chancleta sandwich, a spicy and delicious favorite among regulars, is a must-have!
-
The pastrami sandwich is a highlight, known for its generous portions and hearty flavors.
-
Don't miss the breakfast paninis, especially the one with eggs and bacon, which is perfect for starting your day right.
-
Many folks rave about the coconut oatmeal, touted as the best in town, making it a great breakfast option.
NORTH BUENA DELI (UPTOWN)
Located in the heart of Chicago's Uptown neighborhood, North Buena Deli is a beloved local gem known for its exceptional sandwiches made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. With a menu boasting a variety of options—from classic Italian subs to mouth-watering pastrami sandwiches—there's something for everyone. Beyond its delicious food, the deli features an extensive selection of wines and craft beers, making it a perfect spot to grab a meal or provisions for a picnic at the nearby lakefront. Plus, with friendly staff and a cozy atmosphere, it's a true neighborhood staple that you won't want to miss!
What People Love
Fresh and high-quality ingredients, especially Boar's Head meats.
A variety of delicious sandwiches, with favorites like the chipotle chicken and pastrami.
An impressive selection of wines and spirits at reasonable prices.
Friendly and attentive staff, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Great spot for a quick lunch or picnic provisions with outdoor seating options.
What People Don't Like
-
Some patrons mention inconsistent service and occasional delays in receiving their orders.
-
A few customers noted inaccuracies in their sandwich orders, which can be frustrating. But it's generally manageable!
You Have to Try
-
The Chipotle Chicken sandwich is a standout favorite among regulars.
-
The hot pastrami sandwich is often described as amazing and a must-try.
-
Don't miss out on the London broil sandwich for something truly satisfying.
-
The potato salad is praised as always fresh and a great side to order.
-
If you're feeling adventurous, give the Thanksgiving sandwich a shot!
Sissy's sandwich
Sissy's Sandwich is a charming sandwich shop located in Chicago, providing a delightful selection of sandwiches, empanadas, and brunch items that cater to breakfast and lunch lovers alike. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a favorite spot for both locals and visitors. With a strong commitment to fresh ingredients and homemade flavors, Sissy's has quickly become a go-to place for delicious meals, all backed by friendly service and a welcoming vibe.
What People Love
Delicious and flavorful food that keeps customers coming back.
Friendly and attentive service that makes every visit enjoyable.
Generous portion sizes at reasonable prices, perfect for families or friends.
A cozy, inviting atmosphere where everything feels like home cooking.
A great variety of items, including standout empanadas and jibaritos.
What People Don't Like
-
Some occasional off-flavors in specific dishes, like the tuna salad.
-
A slight odor sometimes noted in the dining area.
You Have to Try
-
The jibarito sandwich, often paired with a sunny side up egg, is a local favorite.
-
Empanadas that are crispy and filled with delicious flavors—truly a must-have!
-
The tamales and sweet potato chips come highly praised for their taste and portions.
-
The cafe con leche is a hit, often highlighted for its fantastic flavor and preparation.
-
Don't miss out on their breakfast sandwiches; they’re reported to be the best around!
Tempesta Market
Tempesta Market is a delightful Italian deli located in the vibrant West Town neighborhood of Chicago. They specialize in artisan sandwiches made from house-cured meats and high-quality ingredients, offering a true taste of Italy in every bite. With a cozy, inviting atmosphere and friendly staff, this spot is perfect for grabbing a meal or trying out their curated selection of gourmet grocery items. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic sandwich or something more adventurous, Tempesta Market's menu has got you covered!
What People Love
Incredible quality sandwiches made with artisan meats and fresh ingredients.
A cozy atmosphere with both indoor seating and a lovely outdoor patio for dining.
Knowledgeable and friendly staff that enhance the dining experience.
Variety of unique and gourmet offerings, including charcuterie and gourmet grocery items.
The sandwiches are noted for their creative flavor combinations and house-made ingredients.
What People Don't Like
-
Some customers feel the prices are a bit steep for the portion sizes offered.
-
Inconsistencies in service and quality, with some reports of missing items and slow service during busy times.
You Have to Try
-
The B. Franklin, a standout turkey sandwich praised for its flavor balance and fresh ingredients.
-
The Dante sandwich, a spicy delight that many claim is a top-tier option.
-
The Southside Johnny, known for its rich flavors and satisfying meat selection.
-
The potatonator, said to be an amazing breakfast sandwich, perfect for starting your day right.
-
Unique gelato options available to complement your meal.
TriBecca's Sandwich Shop
TriBecca's Sandwich Shop opens its doors to sandwich lovers right in the heart of Avondale, Chicago. This charming spot sprung to life after years of pop-up events and has quickly become a local favorite known for its mouthwatering sandwiches. Becca Grothe, with her roots from Western Illinois, crafts each sandwich with care, emphasizing big flavors and quality ingredients. With options for everyone, including plenty of vegetarian choices, this tiny shop is a must-visit for anyone craving a delicious meal.
What People Love
Fantastic flavor and variety in sandwiches, especially the Cubano and Maidwrong.
Friendly and attentive service that makes you feel welcome.
Family-owned with a cozy, community-focused vibe.
Impressive vegetarian and vegan options, making it accessible to a wide range of diets.
Small but creative menu with seasonal and rotating specials.
What People Don't Like
-
Some find the portion sizes a bit small for the price.
-
The seating area is quite limited, which can lead to difficulty finding places to sit.
You Have to Try
-
The Cubano sandwich, often hailed as the best in the city.
-
The Maidwrong sandwich, a must for fans of comfort food.
-
The Spicy Tuna Melt for a flavorful twist on a classic.
-
Seasonal specials that rotate and offer unique flavors.
-
Their donuts, especially the potato donuts, which are a sweet treat you won't want to miss.
Vinnies Sub Shop
Vinnies Sub Shop is a beloved neighborhood deli located in the heart of Chicago, renowned for its no-frills vibe and enormous made-to-order sandwiches. The shop prides itself on using fresh, high-quality ingredients, especially from local bakeries, making every bite a flavorful experience. The friendly staff, often referred to as part of the charm of the place, fosters a welcoming environment, making it a favorite spot for those in the loop looking for a delicious and satisfying lunch.
What People Love
Massive, made-to-order sandwiches that taste fantastic.
Friendly and welcoming staff, creating a warm, neighborhood atmosphere.
Fresh ingredients, especially the bread and meats.
Great value for the quality of food offered, very reasonable prices.
A variety of delicious sandwiches, including popular options like the Italian sub and turkey pesto.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasional lapses in service speed, leading to longer wait times during busy periods.
You Have to Try
-
The Italian Sub, noted for its fresh ingredients and robust flavors.
-
Turkey Pesto Sub, a crowd favorite packed with tastes that keep you coming back.
-
Vinnie's House Special, which is perfect for those looking for something filling and unique.
-
Homemade tuna salad sandwich, loved for its simplicity and taste.
-
Pesto mayo — many recommend adding this to your sub for an extra kick!
