10 Hearty Italian Restaurants in Chicago, IL
Last updated in October 2024
Chicago is a city bursting with life, and its Italian dining scene is no exception. Whether you’re craving a classic dish or something a bit more adventurous, there’s a cozy spot waiting for you. From La Scarola, where every plate feels like a warm hug, to the innovative Monteverde, it’s easy to see why these restaurants are beloved by locals and visitors alike. And let's not forget the exceptional service—all these places make you feel like family as soon as you walk through the door. If you’re strolling through Little Italy, Bacchanalia will welcome you with that family-oriented charm, while Torchio Pasta Bar in River North sparks joy with its housemade pasta and friendly vibes. Whether it’s a casual date night at DeNucci's or a special occasion at Gibsons Italia, Chicago’s Italian restaurants serve up more than just delicious food; they create unforgettable experiences. Let’s dive into some of the best spots that truly capture the heart of Italian cuisine in the Windy City!
Bacchanalia
Bacchanalia is a charming Italian restaurant located in the heart of Little Italy, Chicago. Established in 1979, it offers a warm, family-oriented atmosphere where you can enjoy large plates of classic Tuscan cuisine. The menu features a variety of traditional Italian dishes made from authentic family recipes, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether it's a casual meal or a celebration, Bacchanalia is known for its delicious food and friendly service, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
What People Love
Delicious, authentic Italian dishes made from family recipes.
Friendly, welcoming service that makes you feel at home.
Generous portions, ideal for family-style dining or leftovers.
Cozy atmosphere, perfect for casual meals with friends and family.
Great outdoor dining options during warm weather.
What People Don't Like
-
Some accessibility issues, especially with stairs and limited seating.
-
Occasionally slow service during busy times.
You Have to Try
-
The lasagna, said to be one of the best in Chicago, with rich flavors and generous portions.
-
Chicken Bacchanalia, celebrated for its unique and savory flavor.
-
Fried calamari, noted for being perfectly seasoned and cooked.
-
The baked clams appetizer is a must for seafood lovers.
-
Don't miss the tiramisu for dessert, described as fresh and delightful.
DeNucci's
DeNucci's is a charming new Italian restaurant in Lincoln Park, Chicago, that brings the warmth of Italian-American traditions right to your table. With a cozy ambiance and a menu inspired by beloved classics, you can expect delicious dishes like Veal Marsala and Artichoke Vesuvio, all crafted with fresh ingredients. The restaurant is well-liked for its attentive service and welcoming atmosphere, making it a great choice for family gatherings, date nights, or a tasty meal with friends.
What People Love
Outstanding food quality with well-prepared, authentic Italian dishes.
Great service with attentive and friendly staff.
Warm ambiance that's perfect for casual dining or special occasions.
Popular offerings like garlic knots, homemade pasta, and creative pizzas.
Dietary accommodations, particularly for gluten-free options.
What People Don't Like
-
Some diners experienced inconsistency in food quality and temperature during their meals.
-
A few service challenges reported, particularly during busy times.
You Have to Try
-
Garlic knots – a favorite appetizer that everyone raves about.
-
Homemade pasta dishes like the tagliatelle bolognese and spicy crab campanelle.
-
Unique pizzas, including the pesto pizza and spicy pepperoni options.
-
Desserts such as the pistachio sundae and tiramisu, which many consider must-haves.
-
Artichoke Vesuvio for those looking to explore classic Italian flavors.
Gibsons Italia
Gibsons Italia blends the rich traditions of Italian cuisine with the renowned excellence of the Gibsons Steakhouse brand, creating a dining experience that’s truly exceptional. Located right along the Chicago River, the restaurant not only offers a fantastic menu, featuring everything from perfectly cooked steaks to exquisite pasta dishes, but also provides breathtaking views of the city. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a fantastic meal, Gibsons Italia is committed to delivering a memorable experience filled with top-notch service and delicious food.
What People Love
Exceptional service that goes above and beyond.
Delicious food with standout dishes like the spicy rigatoni and chicken parmesan.
Beautiful views of the Chicago River enhance the dining experience.
Nice ambiance that feels upscale and inviting.
Great for special occasions with attention to detail in celebrations.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasional service inconsistencies, especially during busy times.
-
Some diners found particular dishes to be underwhelming or not up to expectations.
You Have to Try
-
Spicy rigatoni—consistently praised for great flavor.
-
Chicken parmesan—it’s a crowd favorite and highly recommended.
-
Bone-in filet mignon is a must for steak lovers.
-
Banana gelato—dessert that many diners rave about.
-
Brussels sprouts as a side—they're known to be surprisingly delicious.
La Scarola
La Scarola is a charming, classic Italian restaurant located on W Grand Ave in Chicago. With its cozy atmosphere filled with framed photos and lively conversations, it's a place that feels like home. Known for its authentic Italian cuisine, La Scarola serves up generous portions of delicious dishes, from homemade pasta to fresh seafood. The attentive staff, led by the ever-present owner, makes every guest feel like family, ensuring a dining experience that combines exceptional food with warmth and hospitality. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this restaurant is a true gem that captures the heart of Italian dining.
What People Love
Authentic Italian comfort food that's consistently delicious.
Warm, inviting atmosphere with an old-school vibe.
Outstanding service, often with personalized attention from the owner.
Generous portion sizes that leave you satisfied.
Great wine selection at reasonable prices.
What People Don't Like
-
Reservations are often mishandled, leading to long waits despite booking in advance.
-
Sometimes the crowded environment can feel rushed and noisy.
You Have to Try
-
Penne alla Vodka, which many rave about for its flavor and generous portions.
-
The Linguine alla Vongole for a seafood delight that's a must.
-
Homemade Gnocchi that melts in your mouth, often recommended by regulars.
-
Classic Chicken Vesuvio, perfect for those who love hearty Italian dishes.
Lucia's
Lucia's is a delightful BYOB eatery located in the heart of Chicago, serving up homestyle Italian fare that feels like a warm embrace. With a charming deli in the front and a cozy dining area in the back, this family-owned gem is all about authenticity and comfort. Whether you’re enjoying a delicious bowl of pasta or a hearty sandwich, you’re treated like family by the friendly staff. It's not just a meal; it's an experience infused with the flavors of Italy, making it a wonderful choice for both casual lunches and intimate dinners.
What People Love
Home-style Italian dishes that are delicious and authentic.
Cozy and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for a casual meal or special occasions.
Friendly and attentive staff who make customers feel like family.
BYOB policy, allowing guests to bring their own drinks for a personalized dining experience.
A popular deli offering amazing sandwiches and fresh ingredients, making it a hit for lunch.
What People Don't Like
-
Some experiences with service have been inconsistent, leading to delays or issues with orders.
-
Occasional complaints about the food not meeting high expectations, particularly in terms of seasoning or preparation.
You Have to Try
-
The meatball sandwich, often described as a must-have.
-
Eggplant appetizer, which is a hit for its flavor and preparation.
-
Gnocchi, frequently mentioned as a standout dish.
-
The Panna Cotta and Tiramisu for dessert – regarded as some of the best around.
-
The Yale sub, known for its amazing flavor.
Mart Anthony's Italian Restaurant
Mart Anthony's Italian Restaurant is a charming, family-run establishment in Chicago specializing in traditional Italian cuisine. With recipes handed down through generations, they serve up classic dishes like Braciole, Stuffed Artichoke, and comforting pasta options. The restaurant features a cozy atmosphere, perfect for any occasion, and boasts a lovely outdoor seating area. The friendly staff creates a welcoming vibe that keeps guests coming back for more.
What People Love
Delicious, traditional Italian dishes prepared with care and high-quality ingredients.
The warm, inviting atmosphere that makes it feel like a home away from home.
Great service from friendly and attentive staff who make diners feel welcomed.
The cozy outdoor seating area, perfect for enjoying a meal in nice weather.
A true neighborhood gem that's beloved by locals and visitors alike.
What People Don't Like
-
Some diners mentioned experiencing delays in service during busy times.
-
A few customers felt that certain menu items could be bland or overcooked.
You Have to Try
-
The Braciole, known for its fantastic flavor and preparation, is a true standout.
-
Homemade Tiramisu that is often raved about—definitely not to be missed!
-
Shrimp Diavolo or Cavatelli Bolognese, both of which come highly recommended for their rich flavors.
-
The Stuffed Artichoke is a favorite appetizer that seems to steal the show every time.
-
Don't skip the Lobster Ravioli, which leaves taste buds dancing with delight.
Mia Francesca
Located in the heart of Lakeview, Mia Francesca is an inviting Italian restaurant that captures the essence of Italian dining. Known for its contemporary yet casual trattoria ambiance, the restaurant serves up rustic and flavorful dishes inspired by the beautiful regions of Rome, Tuscany, and Umbria. Diners rave about the delectable menu options and excellent service, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors alike. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, Mia Francesca promises a delightful culinary experience!
What People Love
Delicious, authentic Italian cuisine with a variety of flavorful dishes.
Remarkable and friendly service, with staff often going above and beyond.
The cozy yet lively ambiance, perfect for special occasions or a casual night out.
Many options for outdoor seating, especially lovely on nice Chicago evenings.
Consistently high-quality food, ensuring diners leave satisfied.
What People Don't Like
-
Some patrons find the noise level to be excessively high during busy hours.
-
A few guests have noted that the main dining area can feel crowded and congested.
You Have to Try
-
Pollo Milanese, which many fans claim is a must-order staple.
-
The famed Carbonara, often described as perfectly balanced.
-
Vodka e Salsiccia, a favorite among pasta lovers.
-
Bruschette Romana, fresh and flavorful.
-
Chocolate Torte for the perfect sweet ending to your meal.
Monteverde Restaurant & Pastificio
Monteverde Restaurant & Pastificio is a beloved spot in Chicago's West Loop, known for its stylish take on traditional Italian fare. With a menu that features an array of fresh, handmade pastas and unique dishes, it's a place where culinary creativity shines. The ambiance is inviting, making it suitable for both casual dinners and special occasions. Diners often mention the excellent service, which complements the vibrant dining experience, and many cherish the opportunity to watch pasta being made right in front of them.
What People Love
Handmade pastas that are consistently delicious and expertly crafted.
Attentive and friendly service that enhances the dining experience.
A warm and inviting atmosphere that makes it feel special.
Creative and unique flavor combinations in dishes that surprise and delight. Sometimes showcased through rotating seasonal menus.
What People Don't Like
-
Some pasta dishes can be overly salty, which detracts from their enjoyment.
-
Getting reservations can be quite challenging, making it difficult for spontaneous visits.
You Have to Try
-
Burrata e Ham appetizer, often highlighted as a must-have for its incredible flavors.
-
Cacio e Pepe, a classic that many rave about despite some mixed reviews on saltiness.
-
Gnocchetti con Pesto, loved by patrons for its lightness and rich flavor without being overwhelming.
-
Tiramisu, which has received accolades for its taste and presentation as an impressive dessert.
Osteria Langhe
Osteria Langhe is a delightful Italian restaurant located on Armitage Ave in Chicago's Logan Square. Specializing in seasonal Piemontese cuisine, this cozy eatery boasts a menu that captures the essence of Northern Italy. Shoppers and diners alike praise its warm atmosphere, perfect for intimate dining experiences, and the attentive service that enhances every meal. Whether you're in the mood for a romantic dinner or a special celebration, Osteria Langhe offers an unforgettable culinary journey.
What People Love
Delicious and authentic Piemontese dishes.
Warm and cozy atmosphere.
Exceptional service with staff knowledge about the menu.
Great wine selection, especially on half-price wine nights.
Highly recommended for date nights and special occasions.
What People Don't Like
-
Some dishes have been noted for small portion sizes.
-
Inconsistencies in service quality during busy times.
You Have to Try
-
Plin, the rich and savory ravioli dish.
-
Rabbit with polenta, known for its unique flavors.
-
Seasonal risottos, particularly the truffle varieties.
-
Vitello Tonnato, a must-have antipasti.
-
Bunet and affogato for dessert.
Torchio Pasta Bar
Torchio Pasta Bar is a delightful spot in the vibrant River North neighborhood of Chicago, specializing in housemade pasta and authentic Italian dishes. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for both intimate gatherings and lively dinners with friends. Guests rave about the friendly service, often mentioning how the passionate owner, Bill, adds a personal touch to the dining experience. With a menu filled with delicious, freshly prepared pasta and creative cocktails, Torchio has quickly become a favorite for locals and visitors alike.
What People Love
Incredible housemade pasta that's consistently praised for its freshness and flavor.
Friendly and attentive service from both the staff and owner, making everyone feel at home.
A cozy atmosphere that creates a welcoming dining experience.
Very generous portion sizes that ensure you leave satisfied.
A diverse menu with unique dishes and creative cocktails that keeps diners coming back.
What People Don't Like
-
Some diners experienced issues with certain dishes not meeting their expectations, particularly in terms of flavor or preparation.
-
The noise level can be quite high during peak hours, making conversation more difficult.
You Have to Try
-
The Truffle & Fried Burrata Fettuccine, a rich and creamy favorite among guests.
-
The Buccatini Arrabbiata, known for its perfectly balanced flavors and pasta texture.
-
Short Rib Pappardelle, which many claim to be one of the best pasta dishes they've ever had.
-
Delicious homemade desserts like tiramisu that come highly recommended by patrons.
-
The Cacio e Pepe, touted as a standout dish for its amazing flavor profile.
