10 Fantastic Pizza Restaurants in Chicago, IL
Last updated in October 2024
Chicago’s pizza scene is nothing short of legendary, and whether you're craving a classic deep dish or a thin-crust slice, there's something to tickle every taste bud in the Windy City. Take a stroll along the charming streets, and you’ll stumble upon cozy pizzerias that serve up authentic flavors that could make anyone swoon. For instance, Spacca Napoli Pizzeria is a darling of locals, offering sweet, artisanal Neapolitan-style pies and a warm patio setting that's perfect for summer nights. Meanwhile, head over to Pizzeria Portofino if you’re in the mood for a delightful riverside dining experience, where hand-stretched pizzas and a relaxed atmosphere set the scene for lovely evenings with friends or that special someone. And let’s not forget the magic of Zazas Pizzeria for those seeking a New York-style twist. Guests can savor thick slices topped with inventive goodies, while Naudi Signature Pizza charms with its incredible thin crusts and a personal touch from the owner. With gems like Bonci Pizzeria’s creative scissor-cut slices and My Pi Pizza’s deep-dish delights that cater to every dietary need, you’ll discover that Chicago's pizza spots offer a world of flavors waiting to be explored!
Bonci Pizzeria
Bonci Pizzeria brings a piece of Rome to Chicago's West Loop with its distinctive scissor-cut pizzas served by weight. Known for its high-quality ingredients and creative toppings, this casual pizzeria offers a unique experience that lets you sample multiple kinds of pizza in one visit. The atmosphere is vibrant, attracting pizza lovers looking for something new and delicious. With options that cater to vegetarian and vegan diets, there’s something for everyone in this small yet cozy spot.
What People Love
Unique variety of pizzas with interesting toppings.
Ability to choose slice sizes, allowing for sampling multiple flavors.
Crispy and flavorful crust that many rave about.
Quality ingredients that enhance the pizza experience.
Fun and different pizza ordering system, priced by weight.
What People Don't Like
-
Service can be inconsistent and not as friendly as expected.
-
The atmosphere can be uninviting, with noise complaints and limited seating.
You Have to Try
-
Potato ricotta pizza, a crowd favorite that many find irresistible.
-
Spicy eggplant pizza, noted for its great flavor and unique twist.
-
Arrabbiata and burrata pizzas, both praised for their exceptional taste.
-
Sausage and blueberry pizza for a sweet and savory combo.
-
Mushroom rosa pizza, highly rated for vegetarians.
Crushed Pizzeria
Crushed Pizzeria is your go-to spot on Montrose Ave in Chicago for hand-stretched, thin-crust pizzas that are made to order. With a focus on quality ingredients and a variety of flavors, this pizzeria has made a name for itself as a beloved local gem. Not only can you enjoy exquisite pizzas in sizes of 12" or 16", but the menu also includes fresh salads and a rotating selection of bottled craft sodas, making it a perfect stop for pizza lovers.
What People Love
Hand-stretched, thin-crust pizzas with high-quality ingredients.
Outstanding customer service and friendly staff.
Generous portions at fair prices.
Delicious salads that complement the pizza perfectly.
Complimentary desserts like brownies or lava cake add a nice touch.
What People Don't Like
-
Some customers have mentioned inconsistencies in pizza quality on occasion.
You Have to Try
-
The Louie pizza, which is a favorite among regulars.
-
The T.C. pizza, known for its unique toppings.
-
The Rose pizza, praised for its flavor balance.
-
The Victor salad, celebrated for the fresh ingredients.
-
The chocolate brownie dessert, often called a 'lava cake' due to its rich texture.
George's Deep Dish
6221 N Clark St
Chicago, IL 60660
George's Deep Dish is shaking up the pizza scene in Chicago with its innovative take on deep dish. Located in Edgewater, this cozy spot features a unique sourdough crust based on traditional Greek Lagana bread, creating a lighter yet flavorful experience. The menu boasts locally sourced toppings and a rich, sweet tomato sauce that keeps customers coming back. With a strong emphasis on quality and a family-style atmosphere, George’s offers not just a meal, but a delightful dining experience that feels like home.
What People Love
Delicious and unique sourdough crust that offers a lighter alternative to traditional deep dish pizza.
The warm, family-oriented atmosphere with friendly service makes diners feel at home.
High-quality, fresh ingredients that really stand out in every bite.
Variety of creative toppings and options, ensuring there's something for everyone.
Consistently high praise for the rich, flavorful sauce, which complements the pizza perfectly.
What People Don't Like
-
Occasional complaints about long wait times if you don't pre-order, as they sell out quickly.
-
Some have noted a few instances of unprofessional service from staff, which can detract from the experience.
You Have to Try
-
The Clooney pizza, loaded with rich toppings and a standout choice for meat lovers.
-
The vegetarian pizza, praised for its fresh ingredients and delightful flavors.
-
Their unique sourdough crust, which adds a special touch to all pizzas and makes them lighter than traditional deep dish.
-
The accompanying salads, which complement the pizza perfectly and are well-received by diners.
-
Don't forget to follow up your meal with their delicious desserts, especially the mascarpone cake. They seem to be a hit!
Milly's Pizza In The Pan
Milly's Pizza in the Pan is a beloved pizza spot in Chicago, known for its creative take on classic Chicago-style pan pizza. With a limited daily production, each pizza is crafted using the freshest ingredients, resulting in a unique, high-quality dining experience. Whether you're dining in, picking up, or scheduling a future order, Milly's has developed a devoted following thanks to their exceptional pies and welcoming atmosphere.
What People Love
Unique pan-style crust that's both light and flavorful.
Fresh, high-quality ingredients that elevate the taste.
An impressive variety of creative toppings; perfect balance in each pie.
Exceptional customer service that enhances the dining experience.
Limited number of pizzas baked daily, ensuring freshness and quality.
What People Don't Like
-
Sometimes sold out due to limited pies available, leading to disappointment.
-
Business hours can be inconsistent, making it tricky to plan a visit.
You Have to Try
-
The Clickbait - a crowd favorite with unique flavor combos.
-
Untitled #1 - a popular choice known for its balanced toppings and delicious sauce.
-
The Updog - praised for its fresh ingredients and amazing taste.
-
Various specialty pizzas that change and surprise, perfect for adventurous eaters.
My Pi Pizza
My Pi Pizza, located in the vibrant Bucktown area of Chicago, specializes in delicious deep dish pizzas that cater to all dietary needs, including a full vegan menu. Customers rave about the incredible crust and fresh ingredients, making it a beloved spot for both locals and tourists. Although indoor dining is currently limited, they offer a charming outdoor eating area where patrons can enjoy their meals. With a strong emphasis on quality and service, My Pi is quickly becoming a go-to destination for pizza lovers throughout the city.
What People Love
Incredible deep dish pizza with a flavorful, flaky crust.
Fantastic vegan options, including deep dish and cheese alternatives.
Friendly and accommodating staff that enhances the overall experience.
Easily accessible for takeout with efficient service and quick delivery.
The unique spinach soufle and other specialty pizzas are must-tries.
What People Don't Like
-
Not as cozy or spacious for larger groups.
You Have to Try
-
The vegan deep dish pizza, especially with their unique cheese alternatives.
-
The spinach soufflé pizza is a standout favorite.
-
The My Pi Special pizza, loaded with delicious toppings and sauce.
-
Garlic cheesy bread which pairs perfectly with the pizzas.
-
Their thin crust pizzas are equally impressive and worth a taste.
Naudi Signature Pizza
Naudi Signature Pizza is a charming little pizza spot located in Lincoln Park, Chicago, known for its exceptional thin crust pizzas made with high-quality ingredients. The homemade tomato sauce, combined with a blend of four fresh cheeses and fresh basil, elevates every bite. It’s not just about the pizza, though—this cozy restaurant exudes a warm and welcoming vibe, making it perfect for gatherings, casual dinners, or even a romantic night out. Plus, the owner’s dedication to providing a personal touch and a friendly atmosphere truly sets Naudi apart.
What People Love
Delicious thin crust pizza with fresh ingredients and a crispy texture.
Friendly and welcoming atmosphere, often highlighted by the staff's exceptional service.
The honey cake is a must-try dessert that many rave about after their meal.
Variety of pizzas including options for dietary restrictions, like halal.
Strong community feel, making it a great spot for casual dining with friends or a cozy date night.
What People Don't Like
-
Service can occasionally be slow, especially during busy times.
-
Some feel that specific menu items, like the sausage pizza, don't meet expectations.
You Have to Try
-
The Margo pizza, praised for its light and refreshing flavors, especially with fresh basil.
-
Honey cake, which many describe as a heavenly dessert that perfectly complements the pizza.
-
Their square pan pizza, which has a unique crispy crust and a delightful mix of toppings.
-
If you enjoy extra flavors, don’t miss the option of spicy sauce for dipping!
Pizzeria Portofino
Pizzeria Portofino is a vibrant spot along the Chicago River, offering an Italian dining experience that brings a taste of the Riviera to the city. With a charming patio, the restaurant invites you to enjoy hand-stretched pizzas crafted from fresh ingredients. You'll love the relaxed ambiance and attentive service, making it an ideal place for a meal out with friends or a romantic dinner. From delightful appetizers like garlic bread to standout pizzas and an impressive selection of coastal wines, there’s something to please every palate.
What People Love
Stunning river views that enhance the dining experience.
Delicious pizza noted for its unique toppings and flavors.
Friendly and attentive service that often exceeds expectations.
A casual yet sophisticated atmosphere perfect for various occasions.
Great outdoor seating on the patio for enjoying nice weather.
What People Don't Like
-
Service can be inconsistent, especially during busy times.
-
Some dishes might not meet expectations, with occasional reports of food quality issues.
You Have to Try
-
Black Truffle Pizza, an exceptional choice that really stands out.
-
Garlic Bread, said to be delicious and a must-have appetizer.
-
Charred Pepperoni Pizza with hot honey, a fan favorite for its unique flavor.
-
Rigatoni alla Vodka, famous for its rich and creamy sauce.
-
Seasonal Pizza options that showcase fresh ingredients and creativity.
Spacca Napoli Pizzeria
Spacca Napoli Pizzeria is a beloved gem located in the heart of Chicago, renowned for its authentic Neapolitan-style thin-crust pizzas. The restaurant offers a cozy environment, complete with rustic decor and charming patio seating that's perfect for enjoying a meal alfresco in the warmer months. Customers rave about the quality of ingredients and the dedication to traditional pizza-making techniques. It's a popular spot for both locals and visitors seeking an authentic taste of Italy, with an impressive menu that features unique pizzas and delightful appetizers.
What People Love
Authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas that capture the true essence of Italy.
Friendly and attentive service that enhances the dining experience.
A cozy, rustic atmosphere with great outdoor patio seating.
A rotating selection of unique daily specials and innovative toppings.
High-quality, fresh ingredients that create delicious flavor profiles.
What People Don't Like
-
Some find the restaurant closes relatively early at 9:30 PM, limiting late-night dining options.
-
Occasional complaints about service speed and staff attitude during busy hours.
You Have to Try
-
The Margherita pizza, featuring tangy tomato and fresh mozzarella, is a classic must-have.
-
The Burrata appetizer, known for its rich creaminess, pairs perfectly with the fresh bread.
-
Try the Pistachio pizza for a unique twist that perfectly balances flavors.
-
Don't miss the arancini, a great choice to kick off your meal with something crispy and flavorful.
-
Explore the daily specials for fresh, inventive pizzas that highlight seasonal ingredients.
The Slice Shop
The Slice Shop, located in the heart of Lakeview, Chicago, is your go-to spot for mouthwatering grandma-style pizza. With a focus on quality ingredients and handmade dough, each slice is crafted to perfection, striking a delightful balance between crispy and airy. The cozy atmosphere, paired with friendly service, makes it a perfect place to grab a slice before heading to a game or concert nearby. Whether you're in the mood for classic cheese, flavorful sausage, or a unique combination of toppings, The Slice Shop has got you covered!
What People Love
Delicious, crispy crust that balances lightness with sturdiness.
Friendly and attentive staff that make the experience enjoyable.
Wide variety of toppings and options for customization, especially with sauces and extras.
Great value for money with satisfying portions at affordable prices.
A cozy vibe perfect for grabbing a slice before or after local events.
What People Don't Like
-
A few customers noted the pizza can be overly greasy at times.
-
Some inconsistencies with service speed during busy hours.
You Have to Try
-
Hot Italian Sausage Pizza topped with spicy fennel sausage and balanced flavors.
-
Buffalo chicken slice with the perfect amount of spice and a crunchy crust.
-
Grandma-style cheese pizza—light and airy crust with ample cheese that's simply delightful.
-
The vodka sauce pizza, especially recommended with everything on it, makes for a unique twist!
-
Don't skip the hot honey drizzle—it adds an incredible sweetness to any slice!
Zazas Pizzeria
If you're on the hunt for an authentic New York-style pizza in Chicago, Zazas Pizzeria is where it’s at! This artisan pizzeria serves up thick, foldable slices and whole pies, with everything from classic cheese to innovative toppings like hot honey pepperoni. The cozy atmosphere is perfect for grabbing a meal before catching a show at the nearby Metro or unwinding after a busy day. Remember, they only sell slices from noon until 4 pm, so timing is key if you want a quick bite!
What People Love
Incredible flavor and quality pizza, particularly the hot honey variety and the Gold Medal pie.
Friendly and welcoming atmosphere with attentive staff who engage with customers.
Delicious garlic knots and a variety of unique toppings make for a creative menu.
Quick service, especially during lunch hours where you can grab by-the-slice options from noon to 4pm.
What People Don't Like
-
Limited dining space, making it challenging to find a seat, especially during peak hours.
-
The ordering process can be frustrating, as online orders are often tricky, and there’s a cutoff for slices after 4 pm.
You Have to Try
-
Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza - a favorite for its sweet and spicy flavor profile.
-
Gold Medal pizza - praised for its perfect cheese and crust ratio.
-
Mushroom Truffle pizza - known for its rich flavor and crispy crust.
-
Garlic knots - a popular side that complements any pizza.
-
Mike's Hot Pepperoni - a standout for pepperoni lovers!
